Carpe Diem
Age saw two quiet children
Go loving by at twilight,
He knew not whether homeward,
Or outward from the village,
Or (chimes were ringing) churchward,
He waited (they were strangers)
Till they were out of hearing
To bid them both be happy.
"Be happy, happy, happy,
And seize the day of pleasure."
The age-long theme is Age's.
'Twas Age imposed on poems
Their gather-roses burden
To warn against the danger
That overtaken lovers
From being overflooded
With happiness should have it.
And yet not know they have it.
But bid life seize the present?
It lives less in the present
Than in the future always,
And less in both together
Than in the past. The present
Is too much for the senses,
Too crowding, too confusing—
Too present to imagine.
-- Robert Frost
A reality-based blog by Stephen Saperstein Frug
"There is naught that you can do, other than to resist, with hope or without it. But you do not stand alone."
Monday, March 14, 2011
Poem of the Day: Robert Frost Quarrels with Horace's Ode
The famous phrase "carpe diem" -- most often translated "seize the day" -- is, of course, from the Odes of Horace (1.11). In this fabulous poem, however, Robert Frost takes exception to that ancient advice.
Sunday, March 13, 2011
Quote of the Day: the Value of Life
Où que vostre vie finisse, elle y est toute. L'utilité du vivre n'est pas en l'espace, elle est en l'usage: tel a vescu long temps, qui a peu vescu: attendez vous y pendant que vous y estes. Il gist en vostre volonté, non au nombre des ans, que vous ayez assez vescu. Pensiez vous jamais n'arriver là, où vous alliez sans cesse? encore n'y a il chemin qui n'aye son issue. Et si la compagnie vous peut soulager: le monde ne va-il pas mesme train que vous allez?This marvelous passage is definitely from the chapter "Que Philosopher C'Est Apprendre à Mourir", which is definitely in Book 1 of Montainge's Essays; but, oddly, this chapter appears variously as chapter seventeen, nineteen and twenty, depending on which edition you look it. I don't have time right now to unravel this mystery, but would be interested in hearing the answer if anyone does. (I'm assuming it's really twenty... but what's left out if it's nineteen?)
-- Michel de Montaigne, Essais, livre 1, Que Philosopher C'Est Apprendre à Mourir
Wherever your life ends, it is all there. The utility of living consists not in the length of days, but in the use of time; a man may have lived long, and yet lived but a little. Make use of time while it is present with you. It depends upon your will, and not upon the number of days, to have a sufficient length of life. Is it possible you can imagine never to arrive at the place towards which you are continually going? and yet there is no journey but hath its end. And, if company will make it more pleasant or more easy to you, does not all the world go the self-same way?
-- Ibid., as, "That to Study Philosophy is to Learn to Die", trans. Charles Cotton
Wherever your life ends, there all of it ends. The usefulness of living lies not in duration but in what you make of it. Some have lived long and lived little. See to it while you are still here. Whether you have lived enough depends not on a count of years but on your will. Do you think you will never arrive whither you are ceaselessly heading? Yet every road has its end. And, if it is a relief to have company, is not the whole world proceeding at the same pace as you are?
-- Ibid., as "To Philosophize is to Learn How to Die", trans. M. A. Screech
Wherever your life ends, it is all there. The advantage of living is not measured by length, but by use; some men have lived long, and lived little; attend to it while you are in it. It lies in your will, not in the number of years, for you to have lived enough. Did you think you would never arrive where you never ceased going? Yet there is no road but has its end. And if company can comfort you, does not the world keep pace with you?
-- Ibid., as "That to Philosophize is to Learn to Die", trans. Donald M. Frame
Saturday, March 12, 2011
Cool Webcomic
I don't read enough web comics -- certainly given my affection for comics, and the amount of awesome stuff out there. I must admit that I myself prefer to read comics on dead trees -- it matters for me for comics far more than it does for prose, for some reason. But Gerry Canavan, the blogger with by far the best hit/miss ratio in terms of his links being worthwhile to follow (modulo my own interests and tastes, natch) just linked to a new SF web comic called "Cura Te Ipsum" -- which is Latin for "heal thyself", as in "physician, heal thyself". Gerry noted that "the SF starts in earnest on page ten", which kept me going through a slightly slow introduction. The link above takes you to the main page, which displays the most-recent page (they post three pages a week, MWF), but I think it's well worth your while to start on the very first page and read forward from there. So far (I just read the first 57 pages) I'd describe it as an SF thriller; it's tightly written, with very slick and well-crafted art. Anyone who thinks "well done SF thriller web comic" is something that they might enjoy should check it out.
Friday, March 11, 2011
Poem of the Day (and Poetry Site of the Month)
I recently stumbled upon a web site called Poems Found in Translation, run by a poet, linguist and polyglot* named A.Z. Foreman. It's a riveting site, not least because of the genuinely astonishing number of languages he's translated poems from -- nineteen (that's 19, one short of a score) at this count, including Arabic, Chinese, Esperanto, French, German, Hebrew and Russian. For those of us who struggle with any foreign tongues, it's rather breathtaking.
There are a lot of other nice features to the site too. He usually includes a recording of his own reading of the poem in the original -- with what sounds to an utterly ignorant and untrained ear (and at least in French & Chinese, the two I listened to) like a quite good accent. He has a small collection of book reviews of poetry translations, and a rather longer list of recommended books (mostly poetry in translation, but also some language learning materials). His translations also sometimes include helpful cultural hints that help you make sense of the poems. He always gives the original. And so forth.
In short: it's astonishing, and well worth checking out if your interests fall anywhere near that domain.
And -- again, to the untrained, American monoglot -- his translations seem pretty good, too.
Now, like any translator, he has his own theory of translation, and what you think of it will have a huge impact on how you judge his translations. He writes that his translations "are meant to be enjoyed as poems, not scrutinized for lexical fidelity", and that "I have no interest in literal translation, and if my translation differs from the literal dictionary meaning of a word or phrase, I had a reason for it". And while he does occasionally also give a literal gloss, he more often doesn't.
Personally I'm a lot more interested in literal translation than he seems to be, although I agree that both sorts have their use; I think my ideal poetry translation reading set-up is to have two translations -- one quite literal, and one more flowing and focused on being a good English poem. Although I think that the very best translators manage (at least at times) to do both at once -- which is I suppose the ideal of my ideal.
But at any rate, Foreman's good, and worth checking out.
Here's a poem he's translated. It's by the Chinese poet Li Bai (李白), who lived 701 - 762 C.E. First, just for kicks & giggles, here's the original (which I can't read -- I'm just cutting & pasting here):
I can't speak to how faithful Foreman's poem is to the spirit of the Chinese; but I like it very much as a piece of English poetry -- which is, I think, his test. So it works for me.
Go ahead and check out Foreman's site. To get you started, another great poem also by Li Bai is his version of Li Bai's Seeing a Friend Off (pair it with the more literal translation is here). For a totally different poem, I liked Foreman's version of Baudelaire's L'Albatros too. (That's a poem with several different English versions I like; I may try to have a comparative post on the topic soon. Until then, go. Surf his site. Or just keep reading the posts further down this page. Or you could even stop procrastinating and get some work done. Up to you.)
______________________
* No, they're not the same. A linguist is someone who studies language; a polyglot is someone who knows lots of languages. A lot of polyglots aren't linguists, and you can do work in (at least some areas of) linguistics without knowing a lot of languages.
** At the same time, "sh" is also pronounced roughly as we would pronounce "sh"; yet "x" and "sh" are different phonemes, marking totally different words, so that you need to be able to hear (and say) the difference between, for instance, "xi" and "shi", even though they sound (to our ears) like "shi" and "shi". This is just one reason why Chinese is so damn hard.
There are a lot of other nice features to the site too. He usually includes a recording of his own reading of the poem in the original -- with what sounds to an utterly ignorant and untrained ear (and at least in French & Chinese, the two I listened to) like a quite good accent. He has a small collection of book reviews of poetry translations, and a rather longer list of recommended books (mostly poetry in translation, but also some language learning materials). His translations also sometimes include helpful cultural hints that help you make sense of the poems. He always gives the original. And so forth.
In short: it's astonishing, and well worth checking out if your interests fall anywhere near that domain.
And -- again, to the untrained, American monoglot -- his translations seem pretty good, too.
Now, like any translator, he has his own theory of translation, and what you think of it will have a huge impact on how you judge his translations. He writes that his translations "are meant to be enjoyed as poems, not scrutinized for lexical fidelity", and that "I have no interest in literal translation, and if my translation differs from the literal dictionary meaning of a word or phrase, I had a reason for it". And while he does occasionally also give a literal gloss, he more often doesn't.
Personally I'm a lot more interested in literal translation than he seems to be, although I agree that both sorts have their use; I think my ideal poetry translation reading set-up is to have two translations -- one quite literal, and one more flowing and focused on being a good English poem. Although I think that the very best translators manage (at least at times) to do both at once -- which is I suppose the ideal of my ideal.
But at any rate, Foreman's good, and worth checking out.
Here's a poem he's translated. It's by the Chinese poet Li Bai (李白), who lived 701 - 762 C.E. First, just for kicks & giggles, here's the original (which I can't read -- I'm just cutting & pasting here):
靜夜思And here's the poem transliterated into modern pinyin (i.e. the official romanization system of the People's Republic of China). Note that although pinyin uses English-language letters, some of them are pronounced quite differently than in English (e.g. "x" is roughly what we would write as "sh"**); if you're interested, the basic rules are here. The poem:
牀前明月光,
疑是地上霜。
舉頭望山月,
低頭思故鄉。
-- 李白
Jìng yè sīAnd now, following my ideal above, I'll give first a literal translation, and then Foreman's freer translation. The literal translation:
Chuáng qián míng yuè guāng,
Yí shì dì shàng shuāng.
Jǔ tóu wàng shān yuè,
Dī tóu sī gù xiāng.
-- Lǐ bái
Quiet Night ThoughtsAnd Foreman's literal one:
The moonlight glistens in front of my bed.
I thought it was the frost on the ground.
I lift my gaze to view the shimmering moon,
Then lower my head, and miss my homeland.
-- Translated by Adele
Thoughts on a Quiet Night(Note: the link on Foreman's name is his requested citation, which just goes to his blog's main page; to get to his page on this particular poem, click on the title, or just click here.)
The moonlight is luminous at my bedside.
I look and mistake it for ground-fallen frost.
Head raised, I gaze toward the mountain moon.
Head lowered, I'm cold for home and lost.
-- translated by A.Z. Foreman
I can't speak to how faithful Foreman's poem is to the spirit of the Chinese; but I like it very much as a piece of English poetry -- which is, I think, his test. So it works for me.
Go ahead and check out Foreman's site. To get you started, another great poem also by Li Bai is his version of Li Bai's Seeing a Friend Off (pair it with the more literal translation is here). For a totally different poem, I liked Foreman's version of Baudelaire's L'Albatros too. (That's a poem with several different English versions I like; I may try to have a comparative post on the topic soon. Until then, go. Surf his site. Or just keep reading the posts further down this page. Or you could even stop procrastinating and get some work done. Up to you.)
______________________
* No, they're not the same. A linguist is someone who studies language; a polyglot is someone who knows lots of languages. A lot of polyglots aren't linguists, and you can do work in (at least some areas of) linguistics without knowing a lot of languages.
** At the same time, "sh" is also pronounced roughly as we would pronounce "sh"; yet "x" and "sh" are different phonemes, marking totally different words, so that you need to be able to hear (and say) the difference between, for instance, "xi" and "shi", even though they sound (to our ears) like "shi" and "shi". This is just one reason why Chinese is so damn hard.
Wednesday, March 09, 2011
40
I am. Today. 'cause it's my birthday. Happy birthday to me.
John Lennon once said that "God is a concept by which we measure our pain". I think distress about aging is a concept by which we measure our happiness about how our lives have gone. If we have lived the lives we wished to, the lives we feel we were born to live, then aging can be readily and gracefully incorporated into a narrative of our own lives and selves. Birthdays are perfectly happy, about nothing but cake. If not --
I'm not feeling very graceful today.
They say "life begins at 40" -- one of those appallingly kitschy, platitudinous lies that people tell us (or we tell ourselves) to reconcile ourselves to unavoidable bitterness: seeing a skull as a smiley-face grin. But like many lies, this one contains a germ of truth: that life is not over at 40. And that life, while alive, can renew itself. Can change course.
And yes: I feel, strongly, the dark feeling that this, too, is a kitschy, platitudinous lie -- a slightly better version than the previous, but nothing more. More sophisticated propaganda to let us sleep the night. Seeing a skull as a Mona Lisa smile.
But here, I think, is where the wisdom of (a secularized version of) Pascal's Wager comes in. If it is indeed too late, but we assume it is not, what have we lost? Nothing. But if it is not too late, and we assume it is, we have lost everything. In this, the stakes are what matter. Perhaps willing will make it so.
At the very least, it will go better believing this.
So I'll try again. To fail better, if naught else.
What else is there?
Happy birthday to everyone, whether it's your birthday or not. Pretend it is today. That's my birthday present to you. And you have to take it, as a birthday present to me.
So happy birthday. To you. Today. Right now.
How does it feel to be 40?
John Lennon once said that "God is a concept by which we measure our pain". I think distress about aging is a concept by which we measure our happiness about how our lives have gone. If we have lived the lives we wished to, the lives we feel we were born to live, then aging can be readily and gracefully incorporated into a narrative of our own lives and selves. Birthdays are perfectly happy, about nothing but cake. If not --
I'm not feeling very graceful today.
They say "life begins at 40" -- one of those appallingly kitschy, platitudinous lies that people tell us (or we tell ourselves) to reconcile ourselves to unavoidable bitterness: seeing a skull as a smiley-face grin. But like many lies, this one contains a germ of truth: that life is not over at 40. And that life, while alive, can renew itself. Can change course.
"The life in us is like the water in the river. It may rise this year higher than man has ever known it, and flood the parched uplands; even this may be the eventful year, which will drown out all our muskrats." - Thoreau
And yes: I feel, strongly, the dark feeling that this, too, is a kitschy, platitudinous lie -- a slightly better version than the previous, but nothing more. More sophisticated propaganda to let us sleep the night. Seeing a skull as a Mona Lisa smile.
But here, I think, is where the wisdom of (a secularized version of) Pascal's Wager comes in. If it is indeed too late, but we assume it is not, what have we lost? Nothing. But if it is not too late, and we assume it is, we have lost everything. In this, the stakes are what matter. Perhaps willing will make it so.
"The desire for a certain kind of truth here brings about that special truth’s existence; and so it is in innumerable cases of other sorts. Who gains promotions, boons, appointments, but the man in whose life they are seen to play the part of live hypotheses, who discounts them, sacrifices other things for their sake before they have come, and takes risks for them in advance? His faith acts on the powers above him as a claim, and creates its own verification." -- James
At the very least, it will go better believing this.
So I'll try again. To fail better, if naught else.
What else is there?
Happy birthday to everyone, whether it's your birthday or not. Pretend it is today. That's my birthday present to you. And you have to take it, as a birthday present to me.
So happy birthday. To you. Today. Right now.
How does it feel to be 40?
Tuesday, March 08, 2011
Quote of the Day: Randloph Bourne
War is the health of the State. It automatically sets in motion throughout society those irresistible forces for uniformity, for passionate cooperation with the Government in coercing into obedience the minority groups and individuals which lack the larger herd sense. The machinery of government sets and enforces the drastic penalties. The minorities are either intimidated into silence, or brought slowly around by subtle process of persuasion which may seem to them really to be converting them. Of course, the ideal of perfect loyalty, perfect uniformity is never really attained. The classes upon whom the amateur work of coercion falls are unwearied in their zeal, but often their agitation, instead of converting merely serves to stiffen their resistance. Minorities are rendered sullen, and some intellectual opinion bitter and satirical. But in general, the nation in wartime attains a uniformity of feeling, a hierarchy of values culminating at the undisputed apex of the State ideal, which could not possibly be produced through any other agency than war. Other values such as artistic creation, knowledge, reason, beauty, the enhancement of life, are instantly and almost unanimously sacrificed, and the significant classes who have constituted themselves the amateur agents of the State, are engaged not only in sacrificing these values for themselves but in coercing all other persons into sacrificing them.
-- Randolph Bourne, "The State" (1918)
Monday, March 07, 2011
Quote of the Day: Walter Lippmann's Offhand Diss of Landscape Painters
It is like turning from the landscape in the parlor to the ploughed field outdoors. It is a return to the three dimensional world, after a sojourn in the painter's portrayal of his own emotional response to his own inattentive memory of what he imagines he ought to have seen.
-- Walter Lippmann, Public Opinion, Chapter 5
...kinda love the last half of the second sentence there.
Rev. Peter Gomes, 1942 - 2011
Peter Gomes, the longtime pastor of Harvard's Memorial Church, died last week. I heard Rev. Gomes preach precisely once, in June, 1993. But that one occasion was enough for me to list him on my personal pantheon of the Best Public Speakers I've Ever Heard.*
The day I heard him preach was the day of my college graduation. It was the morning benediction, and optional first part of a long graduation ceremony. I got into the spirit of the day, putting aside my Jewish impulse not to go to church, and went. I was glad I did: it was a fabulous sermon, and I kinda wished that I'd gone to church as an undergraduate (I'd gone to synagogue, but for some reason Gomes hadn't preached there...).
As I recall, the text was a lengthy passage from the gospel of Matthew -- Matthew 6, I believe, towards the end, including "Therefore do not worry about tomorrow, for tomorrow will worry about itself. Each day has enough trouble of its own." Gomes began by quoting a long bit of it, and then thundered (if one can thunder with such an accent, one that sounds so stunningly elite that it was hard to feel worthy to sit there):
The theme of the sermon was not to regret what we'd done, or not done, in college: that that was behind us, and "each day has enough trouble of its own". And as one who'd spent considerable time that spring regretting what I'd done and not done in college, and being fearful for the future, it worked wonders upon me, freeing me -- partly, for a time -- from the tight coil of regrets I had wound myself into. God's command not to worry I did not head; but Gomes's advice on this matter helped a great deal. Words well spoken have a genuine magic about them -- are, perhaps, the only things that truly do. And Gomes's words that day were magic for me. For which I will be forever grateful.
Rest in peace, Reverend Gomes.
___________________
* Three others include David Brin, Charles Merrill and my father. (But each of them I've heard speak at least twice.)
The day I heard him preach was the day of my college graduation. It was the morning benediction, and optional first part of a long graduation ceremony. I got into the spirit of the day, putting aside my Jewish impulse not to go to church, and went. I was glad I did: it was a fabulous sermon, and I kinda wished that I'd gone to church as an undergraduate (I'd gone to synagogue, but for some reason Gomes hadn't preached there...).
As I recall, the text was a lengthy passage from the gospel of Matthew -- Matthew 6, I believe, towards the end, including "Therefore do not worry about tomorrow, for tomorrow will worry about itself. Each day has enough trouble of its own." Gomes began by quoting a long bit of it, and then thundered (if one can thunder with such an accent, one that sounds so stunningly elite that it was hard to feel worthy to sit there):
THAT was the Word of GOD; THIS is the Word of GOMES, hardly less important to you at this juncture in your careers.
The theme of the sermon was not to regret what we'd done, or not done, in college: that that was behind us, and "each day has enough trouble of its own". And as one who'd spent considerable time that spring regretting what I'd done and not done in college, and being fearful for the future, it worked wonders upon me, freeing me -- partly, for a time -- from the tight coil of regrets I had wound myself into. God's command not to worry I did not head; but Gomes's advice on this matter helped a great deal. Words well spoken have a genuine magic about them -- are, perhaps, the only things that truly do. And Gomes's words that day were magic for me. For which I will be forever grateful.
Rest in peace, Reverend Gomes.
___________________
* Three others include David Brin, Charles Merrill and my father. (But each of them I've heard speak at least twice.)
Sunday, March 06, 2011
Poem of the Day: Richard Wilbur's Advice to a Prophet
Advice to a Prophet
When you come, as you soon must, to the streets of our city,
Mad-eyed from stating the obvious,
Not proclaiming our fall but begging us
In God's name to have self-pity,
Spare us all word of the weapons, their force and range,
The long numbers that rocket the mind;
Our slow, unreckoning hearts will be left behind,
Unable to fear what is too strange.
Nor shall you scare us with talk of the death of the race.
How should we dream of this place without us?--
The sun mere fire, the leaves untroubled about us,
A stone look on the stone's face?
Speak of the world's own change. Though we cannot conceive
Of an undreamt thing, we know to our cost
How the dreamt cloud crumbles, the vines are blackened by frost,
How the view alters. We could believe,
If you told us so, that the white-tailed deer will slip
Into perfect shade, grown perfectly shy,
The lark avoid the reaches of our eye,
The jack-pine lose its knuckled grip
On the cold ledge, and every torrent burn
As Xanthus once, its gliding trout
Stunned in a twinkling. What should we be without
The dolphin's arc, the dove's return,
These things in which we have seen ourselves and spoken?
Ask us, prophet, how we shall call
Our natures forth when that live tongue is all
Dispelled, that glass obscured or broken
In which we have said the rose of our love and the clean
Horse of our courage, in which beheld
The singing locust of the soul unshelled,
And all we mean or wish to mean.
Ask us, ask us whether with the worldless rose
Our hearts shall fail us; come demanding
Whether there shall be lofty or long standing
When the bronze annals of the oak-tree close.
-- Richard Wilbur
Friday, March 04, 2011
Poem of the Day: Waste Land Limericks
In honor of my students discussing the original for today, I present the classic parody...
Waste Land Limericks
I
In April one seldom feels cheerful;
Dry stones, sun and dust make me fearful;
Clairvoyantes distress me,
Commuters depress me--
Met Stetson and gave him an earful.
II
She sat on a mighty fine chair,
Sparks flew as she tidied her hair;
She asks many questions,
I make few suggestions--
Bad as Albert and Lil--what a pair!
III
The Thames runs, bones rattle, rats creep;
Tiresias fancies a peep--
A typist is laid,
A record is played--
Wei la la. After this it gets deep.
IV
A Phoenician named Phlebas forgot
About birds and his business--the lot,
Which is no surprise,
Since he'd met his demise
And been left in the ocean to rot.
V
No water. Dry rocks and dry throats,
Then thunder, a shower of quotes
From the Sanskrit and Dante.
Da. Damyata. Shantih.
I hope you'll make sense of the notes.
-- Wendy Cope
Thursday, March 03, 2011
Quote of the Day: On the Fragmentation of the Internet
...when people struggle to describe the state that the Internet puts them in they arrive at a remarkably familiar picture of disassociation and fragmentation. Life was once whole, continuous, stable; now it is fragmented, multi-part, shimmering around us, unstable and impossible to fix. The world becomes Keats’s “waking dream,” as the writer Kevin Kelly puts it.It's a good article all around, highly recommended. (I'm a big Gopnik fan, which either solidifies or undermines the recommendation -- I'm not sure which.) And while that was my favorite bit, there were a lot of others that were almost as good. I can't resist quoting two other bits. First, this understated little self-referential sentence from the middle of a paragraph (a little after the above):
The odd thing is that this complaint, though deeply felt by our contemporary Better-Nevers, is identical to Baudelaire’s perception about modern Paris in 1855, or Walter Benjamin’s about Berlin in 1930, or Marshall McLuhan’s in the face of three-channel television (and Canadian television, at that) in 1965. When department stores had Christmas windows with clockwork puppets, the world was going to pieces; when the city streets were filled with horse-drawn carriages running by bright-colored posters, you could no longer tell the real from the simulated; when people were listening to shellac 78s and looking at color newspaper supplements, the world had become a kaleidoscope of disassociated imagery; and when the broadcast air was filled with droning black-and-white images of men in suits reading news, all of life had become indistinguishable from your fantasies of it. It was Marx, not Steve Jobs, who said that the character of modern life is that everything falls apart.
-- Adam Gopnik, "How the Internet Gets Inside Us"
That uniquely evil and necessary thing the comprehensive review of many different books on a related subject, with the necessary oversimplification of their ideas that it demanded, was already around in 1500, and already being accused of missing all the points.And finally, this incredibly nice metaphor (empty if you don't know the original context, but incredibly telling if you do):
[T]he Internet screen has always been like the palantír in Tolkien’s “Lord of the Rings”—the “seeing stone” that lets the wizards see the entire world. Its gift is great; the wizard can see it all. Its risk is real: evil things will register more vividly than the great mass of dull good. The peril isn’t that users lose their knowledge of the world. It’s that they can lose all sense of proportion. You can come to think that the armies of Mordor are not just vast and scary, which they are, but limitless and undefeatable, which they aren’t.Read the rest.
Monday, February 28, 2011
A Very Bloggy February
As it happened, this February was a heavy-blog month for me -- the second-heaviest ever, beaten only by September, 2008. And I like what I've been posting better than those older posts, too.* I don't know why this has been -- I've been busy as hell, and actually working fairly focusedly, so it's not primarily procrastination (although that's some of it, obviously). Of course a lot of them have been just quotes -- but not all, and some have been quotes with so much commentary as to approach bona fide blog posts. Some of them have been inspired by my work (that's a new tag, for the class I'm currently teaching; and I've only put it on the most directly related ones).
But mostly, I dunno.
I doubt it will keep up. But as I predicted early on, this blog has an ebb-and-flow pattern, and this particular month was high tide.
So I thought I'd organize the more substantial ones by categories, so you can look through and catch any you might have missed.
Posts on Pragmatism:
These were directly from my class. ("Pragmatism" by the way, is the philosophical movement, not the political tendency.) The first of them is my personal favorite of the posts this month.
Literary Curiosities and Links:
Things That From a Long Way Off Look Like Flies:
...and, amazingly (at least to me) that's less than half of the posts I put up (not even counting this one). The others are simpler, mostly quotes and the like, but I still think they're all fun (maybe a few years from now they'll look less interesting, but at the moment I think they hold up). So go ahead: scroll through the archives, and have a look.
See you in March!
______________________
* Nothing wrong with them, really; they're just mostly real-time reactions to the financial meltdown and the McCain-Obama campaign, which are less interesting in retrospect. There are some that I posted from that month that I still like, though; here are a few:
But mostly, I dunno.
I doubt it will keep up. But as I predicted early on, this blog has an ebb-and-flow pattern, and this particular month was high tide.
So I thought I'd organize the more substantial ones by categories, so you can look through and catch any you might have missed.
Posts on Pragmatism:
These were directly from my class. ("Pragmatism" by the way, is the philosophical movement, not the political tendency.) The first of them is my personal favorite of the posts this month.
Literary Curiosities and Links:
- 11/02/2011; or, Two Translations of Two Paragraphs of Le Grand Palindrome de Georges Perec
- "I judged vast encyclopedias and books of natural history by the splendor of their tigers."
- The Marvelous Mirthful Madness of Stephen Harry Keeler
- An Ode to My Hometown...'s Namesake
Things That From a Long Way Off Look Like Flies:
- Descartes's Robot; plus: Thomas Aquinas vs. Robot -- to the death!!! (Mostly quotes, but including some very fun & peculiar rumors about some fascinating people)
- My Head May Explode From the Sheer Awesomeness of This (That John Lewis is writing a graphic novel; why I think it's unlikely to be good; why I don't care and will buy it anyway)
- Stray Thoughts on William Graham Sumner's What Social Classes Owe Each Other (A review of a now-obscure 128-year-old book; another post arising from my class on intellectual history)
- Yoram Hoazony, Israel and the Conflict of Paradigms (A political post, but in an overly-intellectualized, name-dropping sort of way)
- Using Dr. Seuss to Illustrate Points in Historical Texts (still another from teaching, this time from the survey class I'm doing)
...and, amazingly (at least to me) that's less than half of the posts I put up (not even counting this one). The others are simpler, mostly quotes and the like, but I still think they're all fun (maybe a few years from now they'll look less interesting, but at the moment I think they hold up). So go ahead: scroll through the archives, and have a look.
See you in March!
______________________
* Nothing wrong with them, really; they're just mostly real-time reactions to the financial meltdown and the McCain-Obama campaign, which are less interesting in retrospect. There are some that I posted from that month that I still like, though; here are a few:
- Some Religious Ideas Are Subject to Scientific Investigation
- What We Have to Fear
- Stephen Frug Muses Upon Illeism
"Its called the American Dream because you have to be asleep to believe it."
George Carlin tells the truth:
But there’s a reason. There’s a reason. There’s a reason for this, there’s a reason education sucks, and it’s the same reason it will never, ever, ever be fixed. It’s never going to get any better, don’t look for it, be happy with what you’ve got.Based on the transcript from here, which also has the video, as well as an interview with Carlin's daughter about the routine.
Because the owners, the owners of this country don't want that. I'm talking about the real owners now, the big owners. The wealthy… the real owners. The big wealthy business interests that control things and make all the important decisions.
Forget the politicians. They are irrelevant. The politicians are put there to give you the idea that you have freedom of choice. You don't. You have no choice! You have owners. They own you. They own everything. They own all the important land. They own and control the corporations. They’ve long since bought and paid for the Senate, the Congress, the state houses, the city halls, they got the judges in their back pockets and they own all the big media companies, so they control just about all of the news and information you get to hear. They got you by the balls.
They spend billions of dollars every year lobbying, lobbying, to get what they want. Well, we know what they want. They want more for themselves and less for everybody else, but I'll tell you what they don’t want: they don’t want a population of citizens capable of critical thinking. They don’t want well informed, well educated people capable of critical thinking. They’re not interested in that. That doesn’t help them. That's against their interests. That's right. They don’t want people who are smart enough to sit around a kitchen table and think about how badly they’re getting fucked by a system that threw them overboard 30 fucking years ago. They don’t want that!
You know what they want? They want obedient workers. Obedient workers, people who are just smart enough to run the machines and do the paperwork. And just dumb enough to passively accept all these increasingly shitty jobs with the lower pay, the longer hours, the reduced benefits, the end of overtime and vanishing pension that disappears the minute you go to collect it, and now they’re coming for your Social Security money. They want your retirement money. They want it back so they can give it to their criminal friends on Wall Street, and you know something? They’ll get it. They’ll get it all from you sooner or later cause they own this fucking place! Its a big club, and you ain’t in it! You, and I, are not in the big club.
By the way, it's the same big club they use to beat you over the head with all day long when they tell you what to believe. All day long beating you over the head with their media telling you what to believe, what to think and what to buy. The table has tilted folks. The game is rigged and nobody seems to notice. Nobody seems to care! Good honest hard-working people; white collar, blue collar it doesn’t matter what color shirt you have on. Good honest hard-working people continue, these are people of modest means, continue to elect these rich cock suckers who don’t give a fuck about you….they don’t give a fuck about you… they don’t give a fuck about you. They don’t care about you at all… at all… at all.
And nobody seems to notice. Nobody seems to care. That's what the owners count on. The fact that Americans will probably remain willfully ignorant of the big red, white and blue dick that's being jammed up their assholes everyday, because the owners of this country know the truth.
It's called the American Dream because you have to be asleep to believe it.
-- George Carlin, Life is Worth Loosing (2005)
Sunday, February 27, 2011
Autoanto and other -nyms
This delightful page gives a list of autoantonyms -- that is, words that have two opposite meanings, i.e. are antonyms of themselves. It's not clear how widespread the term is; the page itself lists a series of alternate terms -- contranyms, contronyms, antilogies, Janus words and enantiodromes. But it's a neat concept, well worthy of a term, and "autoantonym" seems like a good one.
Now, very few of the words are what one might call strict autoantonyms: which is to say, words which can have two opposite meanings in the same context. Sometimes, the difference in context is so clear that even calling the term autoantonymous seems generous:
More often, the words appear at first blush to be strict autoantonyms; but I think that a careful imagining of the circumstances in which the word might be used will show two non-intersecting sets. For instance:
I think these cases are the most common: a thing weathers well (meaning it persists) very differently than a thing is weathered (meaning worn); you bolt a door and bolt away, but it's only autoantonymic if you carefully define one to stick in place and the other to run away; otherwise they're just homonyms. No one would confuse something that's custom made (i.e. unique) with something that is customary (i.e. common); one's things, the other's habits. And so forth. Most are like that.
But there are others, and these cases slide, almost imperceptibly, into strict autoantonymism: the cases blur, the categories get less distinct, and soon you're getting words that are very nearly ambiguous: "it's fine", could mean just fine (i.e. ok), or very fine, i.e. high quality.
In practice, of course, we don't confuse them; the sets, while not strictly non-intersecting, and more carefully defined than it appears. As J. L. Austin wisely said, "our ordinary words are much subtler in their uses, and mark many more distinctions, than philosophers have realized".
But I think that "peer", "rent" and possible "temper" are pretty strictly autoantonyms.
Check out the full list and see what you think for yourself. If things seem strictly autoantonymous, however, be sure you're imagining very precisely the sorts of situations and cases in which the word is used; they may be "subtler in their uses" than you realize.
The same site, incidentally, has an entire page on -nym words. Many will be very familiar to educated readers. but speaking personally I'd never seen:
Now, very few of the words are what one might call strict autoantonyms: which is to say, words which can have two opposite meanings in the same context. Sometimes, the difference in context is so clear that even calling the term autoantonymous seems generous:
strikeObviously, "strike" as in "miss" is a technical term; the latter is the common usage.
• to miss (e.g. in baseball)
• to hit; collide with
More often, the words appear at first blush to be strict autoantonyms; but I think that a careful imagining of the circumstances in which the word might be used will show two non-intersecting sets. For instance:
buckleThe sort of things one buckles are very different than things which buckle; and I don't think there's going to be a case where "seatbelt buckles" might mean that it came apart, nor one which "a building buckles" would mean it fastened. (At least none come to find. Can anyone else think of one?) Similarly "clip" (meaning fasten, as with a paperclip) and "clip" (meaning cut, as in fingernails) are simply used in such different contexts that it is much a pair of homonyms as a single autoantonym.
• to fasten
• to come undone; give way; collapse
I think these cases are the most common: a thing weathers well (meaning it persists) very differently than a thing is weathered (meaning worn); you bolt a door and bolt away, but it's only autoantonymic if you carefully define one to stick in place and the other to run away; otherwise they're just homonyms. No one would confuse something that's custom made (i.e. unique) with something that is customary (i.e. common); one's things, the other's habits. And so forth. Most are like that.
But there are others, and these cases slide, almost imperceptibly, into strict autoantonymism: the cases blur, the categories get less distinct, and soon you're getting words that are very nearly ambiguous: "it's fine", could mean just fine (i.e. ok), or very fine, i.e. high quality.
In practice, of course, we don't confuse them; the sets, while not strictly non-intersecting, and more carefully defined than it appears. As J. L. Austin wisely said, "our ordinary words are much subtler in their uses, and mark many more distinctions, than philosophers have realized".
But I think that "peer", "rent" and possible "temper" are pretty strictly autoantonyms.
Check out the full list and see what you think for yourself. If things seem strictly autoantonymous, however, be sure you're imagining very precisely the sorts of situations and cases in which the word is used; they may be "subtler in their uses" than you realize.
The same site, incidentally, has an entire page on -nym words. Many will be very familiar to educated readers. but speaking personally I'd never seen:
aptonymn (apt names, such as the famous Supreme Court case Loving v. Virginia)...and a number of others too. A number of them seem likely to have been coined but rarely if ever used -- we might term them dictionymns, words that exist only in dictionaries, perhaps? Or even coinonyms, words that were coined but never caught on and are rarely used save in reference to the coining. But, of course, all dictonyms and coinonyms can become real words if we choose. So take a look and see if any meet your fancy.
bacronym (a backwards coined acronymn, in which one starts with the final word and picks words to match)
capitonym ("a word which changes its meaning and pronunciation when capitalised; e.g. polish and Polish, august and August, concord and Concord.")
exonym ("a place name used by foreigners that differs from the name used by natives; e.g. Londres is the French exonym for London, Germany is an exonym because Germans call it Deutschland." -- That one's particularly useful.)
Saturday, February 26, 2011
An Ode to My Hometown... 's Namesake
On being (delightfully!) contacted by an old friend who was passing through Ithaca, I was informed that this blog gave no indication of my current residence. And, I guess, that's right. I mean, there are some clues -- on my about page, updated last fall, I mentioned that we're still living in Ithaca; last fall I blogged about an Ithaca-based book group that I was running; and I've mentioned teaching at HWS, which is in Geneva, NY, about an hour's drive north. But it's hardly blazoned. I should blog more about Ithaca! (Where, yes, I still live. If I ever leave, I promise I'll make it obvious here.)
So, of course, I thought of C. P. Cavafy.
Cavafy is an important, foundational (modern) Greek poet. I was first introduced to his work on my trip to Greece (over two decades ago) when I bought an English-language anthology of modern Greek poetry (this one); Cavafy was the first in the book. He wasn't one of the two Nobel-prize winners included, but he was clearly central to the cannon of modern Greek poetry.
Interestingly, however -- and I only learned this when googling around a big for this blog post -- he was actually born in, and lived most of his life in, Alexandra, Egypt. His parents were Greek, he spoke Greek and wrote in Greek, but he lived in Egypt -- part of the Greek diaspora there, I suppose. I think that's kinda cool, myself.
He also -- and as someone about to turn forty in less than a month, this really won him my heart -- is described by Wikipedia as someone who's "most important poetry was written after his fortieth birthday." God bless you, Cavafy! There's hope for us after all.
Anyway, his Cavafy's most famous poems -- in English, that is; I have no idea what works his Greek reputation rests on -- are "Waiting for the Barbarians" (whose title was borrowed for a novel by the Nobel-prize winning J. M. Coetzee) and "Ithaca", which is our topic here. It was first published, if Wikipedia can be trusted in this instance, exactly a century ago -- in 1911. (Update: In his anthology, Kimon Friar lists it as 1910. Darn.)
Anyone who can read modern Greek can read the original poem here. On the other hand, I suspect that anyone who can read the original doesn't need me to tell them about it. So let's move on to English-language translations.
Cavafy's official site presents five different translations of the poem -- and it's not a complete list. I first read the poem in a translation by Kimon Friar; there also seems to be a version by Rae Dalven, and (another?) by Edmund Keeley without Philip Sherrard's revisions, which have that word in the first line; but most of the reposting I can find online don't list translators at all (highly annoying), and I'm not sure of the translators for any but those at the official site.
Just to give you a sense of how they compare -- I like this sort of thing, after all -- here are the opening three lines in each of the various translations included on Cavafy's official site. (Some of the poems used the spelling "Ithaka" instead of "Ithaca", a spelling which is, I think, more accurate as far as strict transliteration goes, but not the typical English spelling.)
But rather than simply reprint any of those five -- which, again, are already available online on the official Cavafy site -- here is the translation by Kimon Friar, from his 1982 anthology Modern Greek Poetry, which is my favorite -- quite possibly simply because I read it first. But here it is:
(I've kept the original capitalization, rather than changing it to the English standard custom of a capital letter for each new line.)
I find it sort of odd to read this poem as someone who lives in Ithaca -- even though I know that my Ithaca is not that Ithaca, and that for that matter that Ithaca isn't really Ithaca either, since Ithaca here is just a symbol. Nevertheless.
Or maybe it's just a didactic poem by a didactic author. Who knows.
But I will maintain that it's quality survives both its didacticism and translation: and thus I present it to you, Noble Reader, as an ode to my hometown... 's namesake.
(Note: This post was substantively updated after its first posting (once I laid my hands on my dead-tree copy of Friar's Modern Greek Poems.))
So, of course, I thought of C. P. Cavafy.
Cavafy is an important, foundational (modern) Greek poet. I was first introduced to his work on my trip to Greece (over two decades ago) when I bought an English-language anthology of modern Greek poetry (this one); Cavafy was the first in the book. He wasn't one of the two Nobel-prize winners included, but he was clearly central to the cannon of modern Greek poetry.
Interestingly, however -- and I only learned this when googling around a big for this blog post -- he was actually born in, and lived most of his life in, Alexandra, Egypt. His parents were Greek, he spoke Greek and wrote in Greek, but he lived in Egypt -- part of the Greek diaspora there, I suppose. I think that's kinda cool, myself.
He also -- and as someone about to turn forty in less than a month, this really won him my heart -- is described by Wikipedia as someone who's "most important poetry was written after his fortieth birthday." God bless you, Cavafy! There's hope for us after all.
Anyway, his Cavafy's most famous poems -- in English, that is; I have no idea what works his Greek reputation rests on -- are "Waiting for the Barbarians" (whose title was borrowed for a novel by the Nobel-prize winning J. M. Coetzee) and "Ithaca", which is our topic here. It was first published, if Wikipedia can be trusted in this instance, exactly a century ago -- in 1911. (Update: In his anthology, Kimon Friar lists it as 1910. Darn.)
Anyone who can read modern Greek can read the original poem here. On the other hand, I suspect that anyone who can read the original doesn't need me to tell them about it. So let's move on to English-language translations.
Cavafy's official site presents five different translations of the poem -- and it's not a complete list. I first read the poem in a translation by Kimon Friar; there also seems to be a version by Rae Dalven, and (another?) by Edmund Keeley without Philip Sherrard's revisions, which have that word in the first line; but most of the reposting I can find online don't list translators at all (highly annoying), and I'm not sure of the translators for any but those at the official site.
Just to give you a sense of how they compare -- I like this sort of thing, after all -- here are the opening three lines in each of the various translations included on Cavafy's official site. (Some of the poems used the spelling "Ithaka" instead of "Ithaca", a spelling which is, I think, more accurate as far as strict transliteration goes, but not the typical English spelling.)
As you set out for IthakaNot knowing Greek, I can judge these only on the basis of their quality as English-language poetry. And reading through the entire poem (I'm not going to reprint the entirety of all five here; you can go look on Cavafy's site if you're curious), I think that I have a slight preference for the Haviaras -- although, truth be told, I don't have as strong feelings about this as I do about, say, Onegin.
hope the voyage is a long one,
full of adventure, full of discovery.
-- trans. Edmund Keeley & Philip Sherrard
When you set out for distant Ithaca,
fervently wish your journey may be long, —
full of adventures and with much to learn.
-- trans. John Cavafy
As you set out on the way to Ithaca
hope that the road is a long one,
filled with adventures, filled with understanding.
-- trans. Daniel Mendelsohn
When you set out on your way to Ithaca
you should hope that your journey is a long one:
a journey full of adventure, full of knowing.
-- trans Stratis Haviaras
When you start on the way to Ithaca,
wish that the way be long,
full of adventure, full of knowledge.
-- trans George Valassopoulo
But rather than simply reprint any of those five -- which, again, are already available online on the official Cavafy site -- here is the translation by Kimon Friar, from his 1982 anthology Modern Greek Poetry, which is my favorite -- quite possibly simply because I read it first. But here it is:
Ithaca
When you set out on the voyage to Ithaca,
pray that your journey may be long,
full of adventures, full of knowledge.
Of the Laestrygones and the Cyclopes
and of furious Poseidon, do not be afraid,
for such on your journey you shall never meet
if your thought remain lofty, if a select
emotion imbue your spirit and your body.
The Laestrygones and the Cyclopes
and furious Poseidon you will never meet
unless you drag them with you in your soul,
unless your soul raises them up before you.
Pray that your journey may be long,
that many may those summer mornings be
when with what pleasure, what untold delight
you enter harbors you've not seen before;
that you stop at Phoenician market places
to procure the goodly merchandise,
mother of pearl and coral, amber and ebony,
and voluptuous perfumes of every kind,
as lavish an amount of voluptuous perfumes as you can;
that you venture on to many Egyptian cities
to learn and yet again to learn from the sages.
But you must always keep Ithaca in mind.
The arrival there is your predestination.
Yet do not by any means hasten your voyage.
Let it best endure for many years,
until grown old at length you anchor at your island
rich with all you have acquired on the way.
You never hoped that Ithaca would give you riches.
Ithaca has given you the lovely voyage.
Without her you would not have ventured on the way.
She has nothing more to give you now.
Poor though you may find her, Ithaca has not deceived you.
Now that you have become so wise, so full of experience,
you will have understood the meaning of an Ithaca.
-- C. P. Cavafy; translated by Kimon Friar
(I've kept the original capitalization, rather than changing it to the English standard custom of a capital letter for each new line.)
I find it sort of odd to read this poem as someone who lives in Ithaca -- even though I know that my Ithaca is not that Ithaca, and that for that matter that Ithaca isn't really Ithaca either, since Ithaca here is just a symbol. Nevertheless.
I like this poem -- and "Waiting for the Barbarians" too -- but I will admit that, at least to this English-language reader in 2011, they both seem rather didactic. They make Points, and make them heavily. They have a Moral. It's not subtle. Oh, they're both good points, but still: heavily made. I'm somewhat reluctant to label this as a criticism, for a variety of reasons: I'm reading them in translation, which undoubtedly weakens the effect; I'm reading them in 2011, and I'm not sure that they seemed quite as didactic a century ago. And maybe the points (the journey not the arrival matters, a foreign enemy gives a culture focus and meaning although not in a good way) didn't seem so cliched then. (If anyone reading this knows either Greek or the historical context (or both) better than I, I hope you'll enlighten us in the comments.) Perhaps this is a case like the apocryphal reader who thought Hamlet was just a bunch of quotations strung together.
Or maybe it's just a didactic poem by a didactic author. Who knows.
But I will maintain that it's quality survives both its didacticism and translation: and thus I present it to you, Noble Reader, as an ode to my hometown... 's namesake.
(Note: This post was substantively updated after its first posting (once I laid my hands on my dead-tree copy of Friar's Modern Greek Poems.))
Labels:
Ithaca,
Literary,
Personal,
Poems (Entire),
Translation
Tuesday, February 22, 2011
The Marvelous Mirthful Maddness of Harry Stephen Keeler
If you've never heard of Harry Stephen Keeler -- and frankly, there's no earthly reason why you should have --the best place to start learning about him is this introductory essay by William Poundstone. You may want to go read the entire thing, but just for context on what I'm about to quote, here's a bit of it:
I haven't read any.
But in small bits, the man is absolutely, utterly hilarious. Here, for instance, are a few plot summaries, stolen once again from William Poundstone's essay:
But somehow, those just seem to scratch the surface of Keeler's utterly luscious lunacy. Here, via a blog post by Roger Ebert, is a list of characters from Keeler's novel, The Iron Ring.Oh, and this is not some fan's summary; it's from a xerox of pages from the book. (Update: according to an anonymous but authoritative-sounding comment, this is wrong; this did start as a fan's summation, not Keeler's own character list. Ah well. Still fun.) This is pure Keeler, names, descriptions (and missing ones) and all:
And, it turns out, the first chapter of The Iron Ring is online for free! Here's the first paragraph:
If you haven't seen by now why I'm quoting all this, then you never will: it's not for everyone, certainly. Personally I find it so literally laugh-outloud funny that at some points I had tears in my eyes. But I will admit that I rather prefer Keeler concentrate -- the plot summaries, the character list, the selected sentences (below), then the actual paragraph just cited; once you add the water of actual writing it starts to seem slightly less funny and slightly more just, well, bad. But in desiccated form, it's pure genius.
All of which leads up to the following revelation:
Harry Stephen Keeler has a twitter feed.
Yes, some noble soul is posting select sentences from Keeler's work as tweets (plus updates on reviews, new publications, and so forth -- I suppose I can't begrudge them that, although the truth is I do). Here, stripped of the announcements and so forth, are the tweets currently on the front page of the feed:
If you find those half as funny as I do, you can find more by going to Keeler's twitter page and clicking "more" at the bottom, or (if it's been a while since I posted this) there might be new ones up top.
Because damn, he's funny.
Anyone got $18 they want to give me? Because I may need to buy a copy of X. Jones of Scotland Yard.
________________________
* Poundstone comments:
** No jokes about the Republican National Convention, please: it's important to respect our political opponents.
In his time, [Keeler] was pegged as a mystery novelist who also wrote some science fiction. Today, if you've heard of him at all, it's as the Ed Wood of mystery novelists, a writer reputed to be so bad he's good.... his work bears no more relation to Christie or Hammett than does the phone book of Idiot's Valley. Although much of Keeler is steeped in the tradition of classical puzzle mysteries, woe to the reader who thinks he is going to guess the denouement... in X. Jones of Scotland Yard, the guilty party is not mentioned until the last sentence of the last page of this 448-page story....Despite this rather odd approach to fiction, Keeler managed to publish a lot -- well over 50 novels, which just got stranger and stranger. (Some of his later work was published as trilogies just because it was too damn long to fit in a single volume.) Eventually his work stopped coming out in English; for a while his novels were first published in Spanish and Portuguese translation.* He left 16 complete unpublished books at his death. But fear not -- due to the magic of print-on-demand technology, nearly everything Keeler ever wrote is now back in print, for $18 a pop.
Keeler created, and was seemingly the sole practitioner of, a genre he called the "webwork novel." This is a story in which diverse characters and events are connected by a strings of wholly implausible coincidences.... Keeler's narrative style is no less incredible than his plots. Indeed, the two can scarcely be distinguished, for his writing is essentially all plot. Characterization, description, dialog, and use of language hardly exist in the conventional sense. Every paragraph hits you over the head with new and implausible information. There is little room for anything else. In many of his later works, Keeler takes this daft aesthetic a step further. Despite this total concentration on plot, almost nothing happens within the time-frame of the narrative. It's all digressions about what happened off stage!...
In Agatha Christie at her sharpest, everyone is a suspect. In Keeler, everything is a McGuffin, that is to say, an essentially meaningless token that drives the plot. Because the webwork novel is so fundamentally phony, everything is, sooner or later, revealed to be irrelevant. A typical Keeler plot is a fractal shaggy dog story, filled with digressions, and digressions within digressions, that are themselves shaggy dog stories. As in a shaggy dog story, the truest synopsis of a Keeler plot is: Never mind.
...Much of Keeler's writing is genuinely hilarious. You are never given the luxury of being sure it is supposed to be.
I haven't read any.
But in small bits, the man is absolutely, utterly hilarious. Here, for instance, are a few plot summaries, stolen once again from William Poundstone's essay:
A man is found strangled to death in the middle of a lawn, yet there are no footprints other than his own. Police suspect the "Flying Strangler-Baby," a killer midget who disguises himself as a baby and stalks victims by helicopter. (X. Jones of Scotland Yard, 1936)[Footnote mine, not Poundstone's (or Keeler's).]
Because of a clause in a will, a character has to wear a pair of hideous blue glasses constantly for a whole year. This is so that he will eventually see a secret message that is visible only with the glasses. (The Spectacles of Mr. Cagliostro, 1929)
A poem leads the protagonist to a cemetery specializing in circus freaks and the grave of "Legga, the Human Spider," a woman with four legs and six arms. Legga was born in Canton, China, and died in Canton, Ohio. (The Riddle of the Traveling Skull, 1934)
Every resident of "Idiot's Valley" is mentally retarded and packs a gun.** (Several novels; Idiot's Valley is Keeler's Yoknapatawpha County.)
But somehow, those just seem to scratch the surface of Keeler's utterly luscious lunacy. Here, via a blog post by Roger Ebert, is a list of characters from Keeler's novel, The Iron Ring.
- Margaret Annister (awaiting execution in 24 hours for murdering her sister Joline with a batch of poison fudge)
- Big Bella O'John (the prison matron)
- Mrs. Yerxa Indergaard (wealthy socialite)
- Orcutt Buffevant (hotel owner)
- Canace Procunier (comely blonde receptionist)
- Father Clanawly of the Church of the Inception (crooked priest)
- John Very-Bad-Man-Makes-All-White-Men-Tremble (Indian chief)
- Professor Adrian Summrescales
- Beany Rylander (professional age-guesser)
- Lettie Sydeaham (romance authoress)
- Barnaby Gundelfinger (owner of a chamber of horrors)
- Katy Miller (742 lb. woman)
- Harry the Pinhead
- Queenie, Tiniest Woman on Earth
- John and Simon May (Siamese twins joined at the thumb)
- Rodriguez, King of Sword Swallowers
- Bakerby Butterfant (lawyer in the London law firm of Butterfant, Birthwhistle and Thurnbwood)
- Nigel Wimpress (Junior lawyer in the firm of BB&T)
- Moses Gubb (ancient Negro)
- Roul de Sherbinin, Count le Mair
- Bessie Guth (old maid)
- Frank Welso (a crooked weasel)
- Rose Welso (the weasel's mother)
- Bull Buckdavis, Trigger Tatrini, Clubfoot Tatrelli, Guns Considine, Trigger Bozarth, Hoot Ivanjack (assorted gangsters)
- Ms. Hannah Ivanjack (Hoot's mother)
- Hurok Orcutt (handwriting expert)
- Ruth Alberta Frisbee, R.A.F. (glamour photo model)
- Mrs. Gerier (cleaning lady for mastermind criminal known only as "The Brain")
- Ichabod Tsung (popular Chinese radio xylophonist)
And, it turns out, the first chapter of The Iron Ring is online for free! Here's the first paragraph:
Margaret Annister, waiting death in the gas-execution chamber of Nevada City prison, yet innocent completely of the cold-blooded murder for which, within but a half-dozen hours now, she was to inhale deadly cyanide gas, had little hope whatsoever that her last desperate appeal to the governor for reprieve or commutation would succeed. For since it had failed utterly in the hands of her attorney—and why not, in view of her unanimous conviction on the very first ballot of that mixed jury!—and their unanimous decree of death on their second ballot?—and, even more, the refusal of the State Supreme Court to find any error whatsoever in that trial!—how else could this last and final appeal fare in the hands of her only friend, Yerxa Indergaard? But she would know soon now, Margaret realised—with Yerxa’s return and admittance to this place—so very soon!—any minute, in fact—and then—
If you haven't seen by now why I'm quoting all this, then you never will: it's not for everyone, certainly. Personally I find it so literally laugh-outloud funny that at some points I had tears in my eyes. But I will admit that I rather prefer Keeler concentrate -- the plot summaries, the character list, the selected sentences (below), then the actual paragraph just cited; once you add the water of actual writing it starts to seem slightly less funny and slightly more just, well, bad. But in desiccated form, it's pure genius.
All of which leads up to the following revelation:
Harry Stephen Keeler has a twitter feed.
Yes, some noble soul is posting select sentences from Keeler's work as tweets (plus updates on reviews, new publications, and so forth -- I suppose I can't begrudge them that, although the truth is I do). Here, stripped of the announcements and so forth, are the tweets currently on the front page of the feed:
It’s not me, b’God, who intends to worry another eleven years about a striped tom cat and a banana.It disturbs me more than I can possibly express that I think that one of the above is actually a good sentence, and that one other is a sentence that, as a quote from a character in a novel, could easily be a good sentence (depending on the context).
The train station was like an exploded atom--containing 3,491 electrons--scurrying around to prevent themselves being fused into uranium x.
A wonderful man, that old Socialist John Jones the first, considering that he lived in such a dark era as the twentieth century.
Well, she had to tap them on the head with an ax, and cut their heads off--to bring her love to a rounded and satisfactory conclusion.
As the fattest worm always covers the sharpest hook, so do many words in a letter always cover the worst news!
Corpses did not ever rise from their graves and accidentally leave festoons of their spiritual vertebrae hanging on trees or bushes!
The fact might have come out if Dr. Harrowell, an old shark in hangings, had been on the case, instead of that raw youngster Dr. Farxx.
"What does Mrs. Sprudelganger think of my hibernation?"
Not that white prynose, nay. For when he sniffs about, there is, rest assured, within some verdant bush about, a most mouldy bone.
The world of vagabondia must necessarily contain queer human flotsam, if not queerer!
That blooming, blinking, bloody, blatant Monte van Tine has tipped over the receptacle containing the legumes.
A mouse, drinking its fill from a river, gets as much as the elephant--doing the same.
"I know not the 7 and 70 Classical Fables," rasped Kung Mee.
The gal was bleary-eyed when she drooled it forth, but baby, here, had his ears as wide open as the end of the old LaSalle Street tunnel.
My chow dog hath eaten up thy hen.
It takes money to make a marriage happy; not love--nor brats--nor--nor even chickens!
Jesus, but you count your chickens before the rooster has even winked at the hen who's to lay the eggs from w'ich them chicks is to hatch.
Just now, you're nothing but a journalist, which means a newspaperman out of a job.
If you find those half as funny as I do, you can find more by going to Keeler's twitter page and clicking "more" at the bottom, or (if it's been a while since I posted this) there might be new ones up top.
Because damn, he's funny.
Anyone got $18 they want to give me? Because I may need to buy a copy of X. Jones of Scotland Yard.
________________________
* Poundstone comments:
Did Keeler strike some responsive chord in the Iberian soul? Probably not. Keeler had been published in Spain and Portugal during his salad days. [A biographer] speculates that Keeler continued to be published there mainly through editorial inertia.
** No jokes about the Republican National Convention, please: it's important to respect our political opponents.
Monday, February 21, 2011
Yoram Hoazony, Israel and the Conflict of Paradigms
I met Yoram Hazony -- an American-born Israeli conservative, as well as a writer, think-tank founder and soon to be college founder -- back in the early 90's, and attended one of his summer programs (a sort of trial run for the currently-in-formation Shalem College) for a while. I still consider him a friend, although I haven't actually seen him in well over a decade.This means that I am even more interested in his work than I would be normally -- and I think that normally I would be quite interested, since he is one of the more intelligent writers and thinkers working on Israel-related questions around. (Lest you chalk that up entirely to friend-related bias, I should perhaps add that I also disagree with him on a great many points, that our politics are wildly far about, and that I think a fair number of his claims are flatly wrongheaded. (The fact that this coexists quite comfortably with my admiration for his work is a small example of a well-known set of facts which are of deep interest to anyone studying epistemology.))
Recently he's started putting up a series of essays -- blog posts, really, although they're longer than what a lot of people think of when they think of blog posts (although not me, as a quick browse through the "some favorite attempts so far" links over in the right-hand column will confirm) -- under the title "Jerusalem Letters". I've been reading them avidly, and went so far as to write him a lengthy email replying to one of them. He never responded directly (no hurt feelings there: he's busy, I get it), but when he mentioned (in a recent bulletin) that he'd posted some of the replies he'd received to his letters on his new web site, I looked and, yep, he'd posted mine too. I had thought myself that I might rewrite it and put it up as a blog post, but had never gotten around to it; but since it's now in the public sphere, I'll go ahead and post it here, with only minor emendations.
The letter is a reply to two of Hazony's Jerusalem Letters specifically (and while they're all interesting, I think these are clearly the ones to read if you're only going to read two (and if only one, read the first of these). The first of the letters is titled Israel Through European Eyes (from last July), the second is a follow-up titled More on Kuhn, Kant, and the Nation-State (from August). (Hazony has since put up another follow-up post titled EU Council President Van Rompuy: The Time of the Nation-State is Over.) You really ought to go read the original letters, but the on-one-foot version is that Hazony argues that Kuhn's paradigm theory is an important tool to understand current conflicts about Israel, and that Israelis and Europeans are using fundamentally different paradigms to understand the Israeli situation. In my letter, I comment first on two secondary issues, and then on his central point.
And I think it's fair to say that the third paradigm I outline in this letter is the one that I myself hold; and that it is the crucial theoretical critique (as opposed to more practical critiques about the occupation, say) I'd make of the Zionist project.
(What follows is the letter I wrote Yoram, as posted on his web site (no permalink -- but you'll see it if you go to the second of the essays & scroll down). I've cleaned it up slightly -- added a few links and two footnotes, changed a few misspellings, reformatted the quotes and fixed the emphases from *asterisks* to italics -- but it's substantially unchanged.)
I have a very long response to your two essays -- which I think are extremely perceptive, and do a lot to explain differing political views, even though I disagree with you in some key respects -- in my head, percolating, waiting to be written. But I have two books to write, courses to teach, a son to raise: I'm sort of doubtful I'll get around to it. So herewith are three brief responses to three specific points. If they're somewhat weaker, as thinking & writing, than I'd like, I hope you'll try to see beyond them to the hazy fuller text which I may or may not ever get around to pulling out of the Library of Babel (in one of its myriad versions).
So:
Most recent letter:
Now, you may not buy this as a description of America's last sixty-five years of foreign policy -- I wouldn't buy it in quite this form myself, although I would buy it in a rather more nuanced & carefully articulated version -- but it's a perfectly coherent notion of empire, and one with an ancient lineage as a usage.
Earlier letter: "...we have to begin talking about what it takes to establish a new paradigm, or to rebuild an old one that has collapsed."
I read Kuhn a decade ago, early in grad school -- so not in college, but not recently either.* Still, my memory is that he never discusses or describes any notion of rebuilding a paradigm. Once a paradigm is gone, it's gone. Part of this is related to Kuhn's repeated (and complicated to interpret) insistence that his theory includes, indeed accounts for, scientific progress and not just change in world views (so perhaps this is simply not part of the analogy between scientific and non-scientific paradigms which would hold). But in considering what you want to do, it's worth thinking about.
Incidentally, if you think (and based on my memory of Kuhn it sounds correct to me) that paradigms collapse in the face of anomalous facts, what do you think are the anomalous facts which the current European paradigm can't explain or account for? (This is a genuine, not a rhetorical, question -- perhaps a good one for a future letter.)**
Finally, point three, generally on both letters: your description of the European paradigm may or may not be accurate -- I don't feel qualified to say. But I don't think it's accurate for America -- and, for liberal America at least, the other paradigm you present (of the nation state) doesn't fit either. There's a third paradigm that most of liberal America holds in some view or another, which you don't discuss -- but which is, I would claim, a driving force behind much of the criticism of Israel in the U.S. these days.
Very briefly, this paradigm holds that nation states are fine, but that any ethnic distinctions made by those states (or, really, anyone else) are abhorrent. Thus the U.S. acting as a nation state is fine, because it's an ideological, not an ethnic-based, nation state. (At least that's how liberals who hold by this paradigm would define it.) Similarly France, to the degree that it accords itself as an ideological nation state (Liberté, égalité, fraternité) and not simply as an ethnic state of the French, fits too. In this instance what makes Israel a particular offender is not that it is a nation state, but that it is a nation state built on and by an ethnicity. (Think of your colleagues Daniel Gordis's column upon Obama's victory, about how a Palestinian prime minister of Israel would violate its purpose: from the point of view of this paradigm, that purpose is illegitimate because (although not only because) it rules out such a change in Israeli society).
In this view, what distinguished the Nazis was not that they were a nation state, nor that they were an empire, but rather that they were a nation-state built upon an ethnic definition (Aryans good, Slavs bad, Jews the worst of all). Auschwitz occurred not because Jews couldn't defend themselves, nor because Germans were trying to create an empire, bur because the Germans distinguished between Germans and Jews rather than treating all of its citizens equally. - But all this is also rather separate: in the American view the reigning example of national wrongdoing (of which Nazism is considered an even more extreme example, but not the classic example, if you follow me) is Jim Crow: a nation (or a region of a nation) discriminating on the basis of ethnicity (in this case color). South Africa lost the U.S. when we looked and said not, "this is Auschwitz", but rather "this is Mississippi circa 1950". In the U.S., we're not post-WW2, we're post-Civil Rights Movement, at least in what our focus is in these areas.
And it's obvious, I trust, why Israel does not qualify as good under this paradigm.
People operating under this paradigm tend to focus -- too much, in my view, but legitimately -- on racism and other forms of discrimination as the worst types of evil. (I think that liberals would do good to take other evils more seriously -- I personally would make violence, particularly state violence, more central. But that's me.) So since North Korea oppresses all of its population, while Israel (arguendo) oppresses only part of it, that makes Israel more noteworthy. (Although in fairness, nearly everyone who operates under this paradigm (and here I include myself) would point out another, far more salient reason for people in the U.S. to treat them differently: the U.S. is complicit in any crimes Israel commits, through financial, diplomatic and other aid, but not in the crimes of North Korea; it is also correspondingly easier for us to help end them if we should so choose.)
This paradigm also explains why there is a divide among liberal Jews on Israel. Some think that Israel could withdraw from the territories and thereby rejoin the family of non-discriminatory nations (i.e. don't see what happens in Israel proper as Mississippi circa 1960, but only in the occupied territories), and thus support a two-state solution -- but find Israel, until then, to be an extreme offender on the "distinguish-by-ethnicity" count. Others think that the very definition of Israel as a Jewish state is the equivalent to South Africa (or Mississippi) defining themselves as a white state, and that the in-practice quality of life for Palestinian-Israelis isn't as important as the very act of defining and treating differently citizens by ethnicity -- and thereby the only real solution is a single-state solution in all of Israel/Palestine. (Still others would be in camp 1, but think it's now impossible, so are edging into camp 2).
-- I think that this paradigm more accurately captures American -- at least liberal American -- problems with Israel. I think it's a very different beast than the EU paradigm. And if you want to defend Israel, you're going to have to tackle it as well as the EU one.
...Yeah, that was the short version. Long version can be found c/o J. L. Borges, the Library of Babel.
I get a lot out of your letters. I look forward to the next.
__________________
* I hadn't figured this out yet when I wrote this, but obviously this is going to change soon since I'm assigning Kuhn in my Intellectual History course, so will reread it in a couple of weeks.
** Sadly, Hazony has not yet responded to this particular point. I still hope he will, though: it really was a genuine question!
Recently he's started putting up a series of essays -- blog posts, really, although they're longer than what a lot of people think of when they think of blog posts (although not me, as a quick browse through the "some favorite attempts so far" links over in the right-hand column will confirm) -- under the title "Jerusalem Letters". I've been reading them avidly, and went so far as to write him a lengthy email replying to one of them. He never responded directly (no hurt feelings there: he's busy, I get it), but when he mentioned (in a recent bulletin) that he'd posted some of the replies he'd received to his letters on his new web site, I looked and, yep, he'd posted mine too. I had thought myself that I might rewrite it and put it up as a blog post, but had never gotten around to it; but since it's now in the public sphere, I'll go ahead and post it here, with only minor emendations.
The letter is a reply to two of Hazony's Jerusalem Letters specifically (and while they're all interesting, I think these are clearly the ones to read if you're only going to read two (and if only one, read the first of these). The first of the letters is titled Israel Through European Eyes (from last July), the second is a follow-up titled More on Kuhn, Kant, and the Nation-State (from August). (Hazony has since put up another follow-up post titled EU Council President Van Rompuy: The Time of the Nation-State is Over.) You really ought to go read the original letters, but the on-one-foot version is that Hazony argues that Kuhn's paradigm theory is an important tool to understand current conflicts about Israel, and that Israelis and Europeans are using fundamentally different paradigms to understand the Israeli situation. In my letter, I comment first on two secondary issues, and then on his central point.
And I think it's fair to say that the third paradigm I outline in this letter is the one that I myself hold; and that it is the crucial theoretical critique (as opposed to more practical critiques about the occupation, say) I'd make of the Zionist project.
(What follows is the letter I wrote Yoram, as posted on his web site (no permalink -- but you'll see it if you go to the second of the essays & scroll down). I've cleaned it up slightly -- added a few links and two footnotes, changed a few misspellings, reformatted the quotes and fixed the emphases from *asterisks* to italics -- but it's substantially unchanged.)
∞
I have a very long response to your two essays -- which I think are extremely perceptive, and do a lot to explain differing political views, even though I disagree with you in some key respects -- in my head, percolating, waiting to be written. But I have two books to write, courses to teach, a son to raise: I'm sort of doubtful I'll get around to it. So herewith are three brief responses to three specific points. If they're somewhat weaker, as thinking & writing, than I'd like, I hope you'll try to see beyond them to the hazy fuller text which I may or may not ever get around to pulling out of the Library of Babel (in one of its myriad versions).
So:
Most recent letter:
Münkler blames the fall of the nation-state system on the misbehavior of the United States, which he sees as abandoning its status as a nation-state and becoming an empire. I can’t make any sense of this claim. The principal hallmark of empire—the possession of a rationale for permanently ruling over an ever-expanding roster of nations—is entirely absent in the United States. No American I’ve ever met is interested in taking over Canada, although the United States could easily do it. No American I’ve ever met is interested in maintaining long-term control over Iraq or Afghanistan.This only makes no sense if you think of "empire" purely in terms of a military empire, a la Rome. Now, we've had a little bit of that -- e.g. the Philippines, and of course the southwest was won in a war of conquest (which some, including Lincoln in his sole congressional term, decried as a war of aggression) -- but it's not been our main thing. But there are other models of empire, in which economic empire, dominating and economically exploiting areas without directly governing them -- economics backed up with military force which is more threatened than used -- is one. IMS, the Athenian Empire was basically of this sort. And so is the American Empire. Some of our wars can be seen as attempts to keep economically pliable client states in place (e.g. Vietnam). And of course we've knocked over a fair number of unfriendly governments more easily than that (Iran in '53, Guatemala in '54, Chile in '73, etc.) And while no one wants America to directly rule Iraq, Afghanistan, etc, I think some influential people (largely conservatives but also some neoliberals) want to establish friendly regimes, regimes friendly enough to keep bases on indefinitely -- as we are doing in Germany and Japan, say -- for the future projection of military force. So that fits too.
Now, you may not buy this as a description of America's last sixty-five years of foreign policy -- I wouldn't buy it in quite this form myself, although I would buy it in a rather more nuanced & carefully articulated version -- but it's a perfectly coherent notion of empire, and one with an ancient lineage as a usage.
Earlier letter: "...we have to begin talking about what it takes to establish a new paradigm, or to rebuild an old one that has collapsed."
I read Kuhn a decade ago, early in grad school -- so not in college, but not recently either.* Still, my memory is that he never discusses or describes any notion of rebuilding a paradigm. Once a paradigm is gone, it's gone. Part of this is related to Kuhn's repeated (and complicated to interpret) insistence that his theory includes, indeed accounts for, scientific progress and not just change in world views (so perhaps this is simply not part of the analogy between scientific and non-scientific paradigms which would hold). But in considering what you want to do, it's worth thinking about.
Incidentally, if you think (and based on my memory of Kuhn it sounds correct to me) that paradigms collapse in the face of anomalous facts, what do you think are the anomalous facts which the current European paradigm can't explain or account for? (This is a genuine, not a rhetorical, question -- perhaps a good one for a future letter.)**
Finally, point three, generally on both letters: your description of the European paradigm may or may not be accurate -- I don't feel qualified to say. But I don't think it's accurate for America -- and, for liberal America at least, the other paradigm you present (of the nation state) doesn't fit either. There's a third paradigm that most of liberal America holds in some view or another, which you don't discuss -- but which is, I would claim, a driving force behind much of the criticism of Israel in the U.S. these days.
Very briefly, this paradigm holds that nation states are fine, but that any ethnic distinctions made by those states (or, really, anyone else) are abhorrent. Thus the U.S. acting as a nation state is fine, because it's an ideological, not an ethnic-based, nation state. (At least that's how liberals who hold by this paradigm would define it.) Similarly France, to the degree that it accords itself as an ideological nation state (Liberté, égalité, fraternité) and not simply as an ethnic state of the French, fits too. In this instance what makes Israel a particular offender is not that it is a nation state, but that it is a nation state built on and by an ethnicity. (Think of your colleagues Daniel Gordis's column upon Obama's victory, about how a Palestinian prime minister of Israel would violate its purpose: from the point of view of this paradigm, that purpose is illegitimate because (although not only because) it rules out such a change in Israeli society).
In this view, what distinguished the Nazis was not that they were a nation state, nor that they were an empire, but rather that they were a nation-state built upon an ethnic definition (Aryans good, Slavs bad, Jews the worst of all). Auschwitz occurred not because Jews couldn't defend themselves, nor because Germans were trying to create an empire, bur because the Germans distinguished between Germans and Jews rather than treating all of its citizens equally. - But all this is also rather separate: in the American view the reigning example of national wrongdoing (of which Nazism is considered an even more extreme example, but not the classic example, if you follow me) is Jim Crow: a nation (or a region of a nation) discriminating on the basis of ethnicity (in this case color). South Africa lost the U.S. when we looked and said not, "this is Auschwitz", but rather "this is Mississippi circa 1950". In the U.S., we're not post-WW2, we're post-Civil Rights Movement, at least in what our focus is in these areas.
And it's obvious, I trust, why Israel does not qualify as good under this paradigm.
People operating under this paradigm tend to focus -- too much, in my view, but legitimately -- on racism and other forms of discrimination as the worst types of evil. (I think that liberals would do good to take other evils more seriously -- I personally would make violence, particularly state violence, more central. But that's me.) So since North Korea oppresses all of its population, while Israel (arguendo) oppresses only part of it, that makes Israel more noteworthy. (Although in fairness, nearly everyone who operates under this paradigm (and here I include myself) would point out another, far more salient reason for people in the U.S. to treat them differently: the U.S. is complicit in any crimes Israel commits, through financial, diplomatic and other aid, but not in the crimes of North Korea; it is also correspondingly easier for us to help end them if we should so choose.)
This paradigm also explains why there is a divide among liberal Jews on Israel. Some think that Israel could withdraw from the territories and thereby rejoin the family of non-discriminatory nations (i.e. don't see what happens in Israel proper as Mississippi circa 1960, but only in the occupied territories), and thus support a two-state solution -- but find Israel, until then, to be an extreme offender on the "distinguish-by-ethnicity" count. Others think that the very definition of Israel as a Jewish state is the equivalent to South Africa (or Mississippi) defining themselves as a white state, and that the in-practice quality of life for Palestinian-Israelis isn't as important as the very act of defining and treating differently citizens by ethnicity -- and thereby the only real solution is a single-state solution in all of Israel/Palestine. (Still others would be in camp 1, but think it's now impossible, so are edging into camp 2).
-- I think that this paradigm more accurately captures American -- at least liberal American -- problems with Israel. I think it's a very different beast than the EU paradigm. And if you want to defend Israel, you're going to have to tackle it as well as the EU one.
...Yeah, that was the short version. Long version can be found c/o J. L. Borges, the Library of Babel.
I get a lot out of your letters. I look forward to the next.
__________________
* I hadn't figured this out yet when I wrote this, but obviously this is going to change soon since I'm assigning Kuhn in my Intellectual History course, so will reread it in a couple of weeks.
** Sadly, Hazony has not yet responded to this particular point. I still hope he will, though: it really was a genuine question!
Labels:
My Writing Elsewhere,
Philosophy,
Politics,
Reposts
Sunday, February 20, 2011
"I judged vast encyclopedias and books of natural history by the splendor of their tigers."
The internet now has what neither the splendid volume of Jorge Louis Borges's Collected Fictions nor its companion Selected Poems has: a complete English translation of Borges's book El Hacedor, first translated into English as Dreamtigers (the title of one of the stories therein, from which the title of this post was borrowed), but also referred to as The Maker, a more literal translation of its title.* (Of course it is online in Spanish too.)
Those fabulous English volumes don't have it because El Hacedor is a mixture of fiction, poetry and a small "museum" (quotes of others, both poetry & prose), and neither work was concerned to keep them together.
But it was a mistake, I think: the book is clearly a single work of art (in addition to, or rather made up of, multiple works of art that can be read separately as well). Borges is fairly explicit about this , in which he contrasts "the essential monotony of this miscellany" with "the geographical and historical diversity of its themes". He then ends with a story (parable? metaphor?) that could not possibly be more quintessentially Borgesian:
____________________
* The tale of the book's title in translation is an interesting one; Andrew Hurley tells it, tucked away in the notes, in Collected Fictions (p. 544):
** Well, you really should. The Collected Fictions at the very least; I'm admittedly less smitten with Borges's poetry -- I suspect it doesn't translate as well.
Those fabulous English volumes don't have it because El Hacedor is a mixture of fiction, poetry and a small "museum" (quotes of others, both poetry & prose), and neither work was concerned to keep them together.
But it was a mistake, I think: the book is clearly a single work of art (in addition to, or rather made up of, multiple works of art that can be read separately as well). Borges is fairly explicit about this , in which he contrasts "the essential monotony of this miscellany" with "the geographical and historical diversity of its themes". He then ends with a story (parable? metaphor?) that could not possibly be more quintessentially Borgesian:
A man sets himself the task of portraying the world. Through the years he peoples a space with images of provinces, kingdoms, mountains, bays, ships, islands, fishes, rooms, instruments, stars, horses, and people. Shortly before his death, he discovers that that patient labyrinth of lines traces the image of his face.So now if you want to read it in English in its entirety (without flipping back and forth between two volumes, or buying a third whose contents you already own**), you can now do so thanks to the internet, this astonishing web of words of whom Borges was, as much as any other thinker, the spiritual grandfather.
____________________
* The tale of the book's title in translation is an interesting one; Andrew Hurley tells it, tucked away in the notes, in Collected Fictions (p. 544):
The Spanish title of this "heterogeneous" volume of prose and poetry... is El hacedor, and hacedor is a troublesome word for a translator into English. JLB seems to be thinking of the Greek word poeta, which means "maker", since a "true and literal" translation of poeta into Spanish would indeed be hacedor. Yet hacedor is in this translator's view, and in the view of all those native speakers he has consulted, a most uncommon word. It is not used in Spanish for "poet" but instead makes one think of someone who makes things with his hands, a kind of artisan, perhaps, or perhaps even a tinkerer. The English word maker is perhaps strange too, yet it exists; however, it is used in English (in such phrases as "he went to meet his Maker" and the brand name Maker's Mark) in a way that dissuades one from seizing upon it immediately as the "perfect" translation of hacedor. (The Spanish word hacedor would never be used for "God," for instance.) Eliot Weingerger has suggested to me, quite rightly, perhaps, that JLB had in mind the Scots word makir, which means "poet." But there are other cases: Eliot's dedication of The Waste Land to Ezra Pound, taken from Dante -- il miglior fabbro, where fabbro has exactly the same range as hacedor. Sever considerations seem to militate in favor of the translation "artificer": first, the sense of someone's making something with his hands, or perhaps "sculptor," for one of JLB's favorite metaphors for poetry was at one time sculpture; second, the fact that the second "volume" in the volume Fictions [a.k.a. Ficciones] is clearly titled Artifices; third, the overlap between art and craft or artisanry that is implied in the word, as in the first story in this volume. But a translational decision of this kind is never easy and perhaps never "done"; one wishes one could call the volume Il fabbro, or Poeta, or leave it El hacedor. The previous English translation of this volume in fact opted for Dreamtigers. Yet sometimes a translator is spared this anguish (if he or she finds the key to the puzzle in time to forestall it); in this case there is an easy solution. I quote from Emir Rodriguez Monegal's Jorge Louis Borges: A Literary Biography, p. 438: "Borges was sixty when the ninth volume of his complete works came out... For the new book he had thought up the title in English: The Maker, and had translated it into Spanish as El hacedor; but when the book came out in the United Sates the American translator preferred to avoid the theological implications and used instead the title of one of the pieces: Dreamtigers." And so a translation problem becomes a problem created in the first place by a translation!
** Well, you really should. The Collected Fictions at the very least; I'm admittedly less smitten with Borges's poetry -- I suspect it doesn't translate as well.
Saturday, February 19, 2011
Using Dr. Seuss to Illustrate Points in Historical Texts
There are odd pedagogical moves one finds oneself making when both a teacher and a parent.
This past week I was conducting a detailed discussion and analysis of Madison's Federalist 10 in class, trying to really break down and convey the argument in all its detail, and we came to the following passage (the second half; the first is quoted for context):
(I know, I know: a real scholar would have mentioned this instead.)
This past week I was conducting a detailed discussion and analysis of Madison's Federalist 10 in class, trying to really break down and convey the argument in all its detail, and we came to the following passage (the second half; the first is quoted for context):
The latent causes of faction are thus sown in the nature of man; and we see them everywhere brought into different degrees of activity, according to the different circumstances of civil society.... So strong is this propensity of mankind to fall into mutual animosities that where no substantial occasion presents itself, the most frivolous and fanciful distinctions have been sufficient to kindle their unfriendly passions and excite their most violent conflicts.And as I was explaining what this meant (for unlike the idea that factions might be caused by religious differences, differences in philosophy of government, differences in property, etc, which my students got more-or-less on their own, this one was giving them difficulty), I quoted the following illustration of the point:
Now, the Star-Bell Sneetches had bellies with stars.What can I say? It was a text I thought they'd all have read, anyway. I think it got the point across.
The Plain-Belly Sneetches had none upon thars.
Those stars weren’t so big. They were really so small.
You might think such a thing wouldn’t matter at all.
But, because they had stars, all the Star-Belly Sneetches
Would brag, “We’re the best kind of Sneetch on the beaches.”
With their snoots in the air, they would sniff and they’d snort
“We’ll have nothing to do with the Plain-Belly sort!”
And, whenever they met some, when they were out walking,
They’d hike right on past them without even talking....
They left them out cold, in the dark of the beaches.
They kept them away. Never let them come near.
-- Dr. Seuss, The Sneetches
(I know, I know: a real scholar would have mentioned this instead.)
Friday, February 18, 2011
Nine Planets Again?
Despite Pluto's demotion, there may be nine planets after all. And no, I'm not talking about Eris (the larger-and-farther-out-than-Pluto object that never even briefly got to be a planet, but went straight into the "dwarf planet" kill-file). This one is bigger than that. Bigger than Jupiter.
If it exists. Right now, they're not quite sure:
And of course, those spoilsport scientists may find away to make this not a planet too:
Here's an image the Independent did (link to the original pdf) showing where Tyche would be (if it exists -- again, still not proven):
Wildly cool, says I.
If it exists. Right now, they're not quite sure:
The hunt is on for a gas giant up to four times the mass of Jupiter thought to be lurking in the outer Oort Cloud, the most remote region of the solar system. The orbit of Tyche (pronounced ty-kee), would be 15,000 times farther from the Sun than the Earth's, and 375 times farther than Pluto's, which is why it hasn't been seen so far.Stay tuned! Breaking!
But scientists now believe the proof of its existence has already been gathered by a Nasa space telescope, Wise, and is just waiting to be analysed.
The first tranche of data is to be released in April, and astrophysicists John Matese and Daniel Whitmire from the University of Louisiana at Lafayette think it will reveal Tyche within two years.
And of course, those spoilsport scientists may find away to make this not a planet too:
Whether it would become the new ninth planet would be decided by the International Astronomical Union (IAU). The main argument against is that Tyche probably formed around another star and was later captured by the Sun's gravitational field. The IAU may choose to create a whole new category for Tyche, Professor Matese said.Jeeze, waddya want? Pluto's too small, Tyche's an illegal immigrant...
Here's an image the Independent did (link to the original pdf) showing where Tyche would be (if it exists -- again, still not proven):
Wildly cool, says I.
Thursday, February 17, 2011
Snarky Academic Comment of the Day
In later years Dewey deliberately adopted an antirhetorical style, in the belief that readers should be persuaded by the cogency of the thought rather than the felicities of the prose. He was uncommonly successful in getting rid of the felicities.
-- Louis Menand, The Metaphysical Club, p. 304
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

