Saturday, September 06, 2008

Simple Answers to Simple Questions

Andrew Sullivan on William Kristol: "Is everything about pursuing power by any means to him?"

Yes.

This has been another edition of simple answers to simple questions.

(Simple answers to simple questions ™ Atrios.)

Friday, September 05, 2008

Punking the Press

One of the central dynamics of our political age -- and one of the central analytical insights returned to in the left-wing blogosphere again and again -- is the degree to which the mainstream press has been cowed by the right over the past decades. This is the dynamic underlying the "opinions on the shape of earth differ" style of journalism that is such a bane in our country. It is most importantly expressed in the by-now familiar, even banal, pairing of explicitly conservative pundits with supposedly objective reporters as ideological balance -- or, on a broader level, the fact that we now have two types of media in this country: cowed, "balanced" supposedly objective media, and overtly conservative propaganda (FOX).

This has been so essential to the success of the conservative movement because, of course, reality has a well-known liberal bias: so that, however tepidly, objective journalists will end up supporting liberal analyses if they do their jobs. But if this is balanced against lies and distortion from the right, then we end up not with fact-based journalism, but two views on the flatness of the earth which the public has no way of evaluating (having neither the time nor the expertise to do so -- while those with it are busy pairing lies and truth as balance).

But of course the successful working of the refs goes far beyond this; this is why the right can throw hissy fits when subjected to a hundredth of the sort of political questioning they themselves throw at the left. (Reasonable questions about Sarah Palin are shocking, shocking, after a summer of pure mud-slinging at Obama -- to take just the most recent example.)

Another aspect of this is the shedding of the traditions and practices of journalism, traditions and practices which developed to ensure accuracy and fairness (and thus support liberal positions if followed through on). Thus reporters will now endure a choreographed circus, with a prearranged list of reporters who will be called on and no follow-ups as the main Presidential meeting of the press days before a war -- and pretend it was a real press conference.

Now they're shedding the next tradition -- the idea that major candidates for national office, such as the Republican candidate for Vice President, should have to actually answer questions from the press and appear in non-scripted settings:
Sarah Palin will, after a brief stretch on the trail, head back to Anchorage and away from the national media.... She also seems unlikely to do many major media interviews between now and then, and the campaign seems to feel no urgency about putting her on the Sunday shows.... According to Nicole Wallace of the McCain campaign, the American people don't care whether Sarah Palin can answer specific questions about foreign and domestic policy. According to Wallace -- in an appearance I did with her this morning on Joe Scarborough's show -- the American people will learn all they need to know (and all they deserve to know) from Palin's scripted speeches and choreographed appearances on the campaign trail and in campaign ads.
Steve Benen, my source for those quotes, notes that "this really isn't a vote of confidence in Palin's readiness". And that's true enough. But it is a vote of confidence in the press's willingness to roll over for anything the Republicans however ludicrous their actions.

Now, if a Democrat had made such a weak VP pick, and then followed it up by burying them away from the press without a single press conference, every newspaper, every TV show, every web site would be running headline stories daily about how ludicrous this was, quoting the outrage of Republicans at how laughable this was and the right of the people to see candidates for national office, displaying clocks showing the time since Palin's last press conference, and so on.

But the Republicans have punked the national media so much, over and over, for the past decades that they expect they to just take it. And, of course, having been punked, over and over, for decades, it's hard to imagine the press will call the McCain campaign on this. (After all, they were just punked in the last week, drawing back from their genuine questions about Palin when the McCain campaigned threw the by-the-number Republican hissy fit). The press has learned fear and compliance against the right-wing machine.

But over the summer we saw some small signs of life from the SCLM in the face of McCain's onslaught of negativity and lies. Long-time tools such as Joe Klein found their journalistic backbone, and called on their colleagues to do likewise.

So now the question is: will the media swallow this? Or will they create such a storm that the McCain campaign is forced to change course and let their VP candidate hold a few (unrestricted) press conferences?

The Republicans have just come up to the media and said: "Get gone, suckers. This corner is ours now."

Will the media come back? Or will they, once again, slink away?

C'mon, you cowards: are you really going to just take this? This?

We're about to find out.

Update: Kevin Drum argues that rather than being punked the media is being played:
Howard Fineman, Ben Smith, and Chuck Todd are all reporting the same thing: the McCain campaign is going to whisk Sarah Palin back to Alaska and then have her hole up for a good long while until they think it's safe for her to talk to the press.... But I say: don't believe it. These guys are being suckered with misinformation so that the McCain campaign will have yet another excuse to pretend that the media is bent on making up egregious lies about Palin. I don't think she's going to be talking to a horde of serious national journalists, but they'll pick some spots and do a few remotes. Maybe Larry King, despite pulling out of his show a few days ago. One or more of the morning shows. Some simpatico outlets like Fox News or the New York Post or the Wall Street Journal edit page. That kind of thing.
Sounds plausible: no real interviews, but lots of fake ones, and complaining about media bias on top of it.

And yes, if the media is being played, I just walked right into it. Played along with the rest of them. (Since leftie outrage will be part of the story, essential to the success of the disinformation, if indeed it is such.) Great. Well done, Frug. Hats off to that one.

Update 2: ...although it occurs to me that, if this is their strategy, they're taking an awful risk: leaking this story, then having her give any interviews, even to fake news outlets like Fox, might look like the McCain campaign is giving in to any outrage over this. And while the SCLM is usually cowed, nothing gets them going like signs of weakness: if they sense this, they'll pile on. So if this is the plan, it's a risky one, and it might not work.

(This, perhaps, is why the media is so often so easily punked by the right: they're bullies, and like many bullies, are only interested in weak targets, and are themselves easily scared and pushed around by bigger bullies. -- Whereas the left, cowing before both the media and the right, have been, for decades more than willing to grovel before both. As many bloggers (particularly Digby, although I don't have specific links at hand) have noted, it is this, and not any actual stances on any issues (national security or otherwise) that makes the left look so weak: their willingness to be so often punked not only by the right but by the media, beaten up by both bullies and the bullies of bullies. God, what a political culture we have.)

Update 3: So Digby, who is a very acute observer of the contemporary political scene, thinks that yet a third thing is going on:
They are going to work themselves into a frenzy over this. And the right will hold Palin off just long enough for the outcry to become deafening. And then Palin will appear in front of a gargantuan television audience (again) on something like 60 Minutes --- and do quite well. They are already working the media hard to make sure they don't go for the jugular -- and they won't. People need to get over the idea that Palin's some kind of Britney Spears bimbo. She's a professional politician and from the looks of it, a pretty good one. She's not going to fall on her face on TV. They will build the expectations accordingly.
In other words, it's an expectations game. Certainly also plausible. But her co-blogger, Tristero, has an interpretation more in line with mine, that this is "part and parcel of a campaign to terminate unscripted, uncontrolled situations."

Digby also sneers at the notion that "submitting to Chris Matthews' questions ever told voters anything meaningful about the candidates." And I get her point. The political journalists in this country are, well, sorrowful. But for Pete's sake, is only showing choreographed sessions or puff pieces better? If I -- and Tristero -- are right, then the basic principle of having no "unscripted, uncontrolled situations" is terrible enough to fight, even if the unscripted situations are with journalists like Chris Matthews.

Incidentally, FWIW, Kevin Drum seems to have changed his mind -- due to a confirmation of the story by Marc Ambinder, if I read Drum correctly -- and now thinks that "The McCain campaign is scared to death.... So they're keeping her in the deep freeze."

Finally, Drum says that "it's sort of a test of just how gullible the American public really is," while Tristero wonders "Will the Democrats scream bloody murder about this outrageous attempt to run a presidential campaign without the opportunity actually to question one party's candidates in a frank manner?" -- two different candidates for challenging this than the media, as I suggested above. Frankly, I'd hope for all three. But it seems to me that the Dems screaming will just make this sound like yet another partisan pissing match, while the base of the public's information is what's at issue here. So yeah, both -- especially the public -- but I still hope that the media will step up to the plate on this one.

'Cause, y'know, I'm idealistic, starry-eyed and naive that way.

Thursday, September 04, 2008

McClouding Chrome

Scott McCloud has written a comic about Google's new browser, Chrome.

You can read McCloud's comic either here, or with a slightly different interface here. (Update: An even better interface is here.) McCloud has a brief FAQ about the comic up on his web site here.


(Image adapted from a self-portrait by Scott McCloud (found
here) by using the "Chrome" filter in Photoshop.)

I have to say, it was very clever of Google to hire McCloud to do an introduction to their comic. While I admit my attention drifted a bit in chapter two, for the most part it was quite successful in getting me to want to try their new browser. (My main computer is in the shop at the moment, so I ain't downloading anything major now, but I'll probably try it once it gets back.) it certainly sounds like it'll fix some of the frustrations of the all-too-frequently crashy Firefox, which is the main browser I use at the moment. (Update: Actually, I won't be trying it, since I just learned (here) that there is no mac version.)

Of course, it's supposed to make the browser sound good: it's basically an ad -- aka propaganda. Sort of the comics equivalent of an infomercial. But it's an informative one, with far better production values than most; and -- most importantly -- it's an entertaining one. (And of course all this adds up to it being, for me at least, an effective one.)

One thing to note about the comic is that it's fairly substantial: when I first saw a link to it (here), I assumed it would be a brief introduction of perhaps a few pages. But actually it's a full 38 page comic -- not a minor work at all. And it goes into a fair amount of detail about what they were trying to do with the browser -- the problems they were trying to fix, the features they were trying to add, and that sort of thing.


An excerpt from p. 27 of McCloud's Google Chrome.

As a long time reader & fan of McCloud's nonfiction comics, it was interesting to read one which -- while very much in his familiar style -- did not feature his familiar avatar, but rather showed a host of other figures in its place. (It was interesting, for example, to see how his standard gestures worked when others did them -- or what replaced those gestures in similar situations.) I will say that I think the comic would have been slightly more effective with a single tour guide, although that's a minor point.

My main complaint about the comic is that -- quite oddly for a McCloud comic -- it isn't really well adapted to the web: it's a print comic scanned in, with all the awkwardness inherent in that format (an awkwardness that has never been better explained than by McCloud himself). He says that they're working on a better interface, and I hope that's true. I certainly can't imagine that many people will print the thing out, so I don't know why they (McCloud? Google?) chose that format -- maybe they're printing it to distribute? Still, rather odd.

Despite this, it's still an interesting & entertaining comic, if you don't mind reading admitted advertising.

Update: John Brownlee at BoingBoing Gadgets offers a different view:
Scott McCloud's 38-page "Google Chrome" comic was just so insufferably smug, self-important and impenetrable that we're still trying to knead out the resulting big rubbery one long enough to actually install the damn thing... McCloud's comic was so filled with ill-defined, meaningless technobabble that it made a complete mockery of his masterpiece, Understanding Comics. Valleywag's Paul Boutin brilliantly observes that the whole thing reads "like the middle of a Neal Stephenson novel."
Well, that explains why I got lost in part two. But overall, personally, I liked it more than that.

Also -- the point of his post -- Brownlee links to this round-up of parodies of McCloud's comic. Follow the links in that post for more parodies (it's really astonishing how many there are already!) -- I liked this one and this one myself. The latter ironically has a more McCloudian interface than the original.

A Grand Unified Theory of Palin Speech Reactions

There seem to be two major schools of thought: that Palin did fabulously, and that Palin gave a speech that will resonate only with the Republican base, full of attacks and talking points and no solutions (oh, and yes: a whole lot of lies). Josh Marshall encapsulates the two schools of thought here:
I know I'm swimming upstream against a stiff current. But I'll stick to my first impression. I think Mike Allen is nuts to call the Palin speech a grand slam. For partisan Republicans, absolutely. It's a bad year for Republicans and the desire for something or someone to get excited about is palpable. And they got it. But there's only so much more consolidating of the Republican base McCain can do. As good as her delivery was, I really don't think this was a speech that spoke to the issues that are driving the election this year. I don't think it's a slashing attacks against liberal elites kind of year.
But perhaps there is a way to cut this particular Gordian Knot, and understand both as true. Some commentators in the mainstream media thought that Palin's speech -- designed to please primarily the Republican base -- was a "grand slam" because they are part of that base. The so-called liberal media loves "slashing attacks against liberal elites" (even though they are, themselves, elites, who often self-identify as liberal, however much the designation fails to truly fit). After eight years of disastrous conservative governance, only the rabid republican base could see liberalism as the problem: but the SCLM are definitely in that camp.

And no surprise: this is the group that was, for years, McCain's "base". They eat up this stuff. So when Palin fed read meat to the base, Mike Allen heard a grand slam. Because the speech was designed for him.

The only question is will enough Americans hear not the speech but the spin; or hear the speech without anyone to question the lies and distortions (since the SCLM doesn't seem that interested). In which case it might actually work. When the media's your base, playing to the base is particularly powerful.

Update: For a great analysis of precisely how Palin appealed to her base, read Rick Perlstein's blow-by-blow. (Via)

Wednesday, September 03, 2008

Stephen Frug Muses Upon Illeism

From the department of phenomena-you-didn't-know- there-was-a-word-for, we have today's vocabulary word (stumbled upon here): Illeism: "the act of referring to oneself in the third person" (from the Latin ille, that). One who practices illeism is an illeist.

Language log has a quick tour of the subject here, complete with a Zippy the Pinhead cartoon about (apparently well-known illeist) Salvador Dali, and the Wikipedia article has a charming list of examples. These include a fair number of politicians -- most famously (in recent US politics) Bob Dole, but apparently dating back to Julius Caesar -- a fair number of sports stars and similar celebrities, and an impressive list of fictional characters. The latter category includes Shakespeare's Julius Caesar, Elmo from Sesame Street, Marvel Comics's Hulk and Doctor Doom, The Wire's Omar, Cerebus the Aardvark, The Dude from The Big Lebowski, Gollum, several Simpsons characters (such as Groundskeeper Willie), and (apparently) Tarzan.

Technically, illeism is any reference to oneself in the third person, such as the blogger writing this sentence is doing in it, but the most notable sort of illeism is when one refers to oneself by name. Language Log calls this proper-name illeism, and breaks it down into binomial* ("Bob Dole isn't a fringe candidate"), last name only ("You don't have Nixon to kick around any more") and first name only ("Omar don't scare.") This doesn't include people (and other creatures) known only by one name (Cerebus, Gollum, Hulk) nor by a nickname (The Dude), and I don't know where to categorize "Groundskeeper Willie".

I'm curious about the meaning of this device -- in particular, what it says about fictional characters when they do this. (I don't know if anyone's written about this, although this article discusses Shakespeare's use of proper-name illeism (called in the article "illeism with a difference") in several of his plays.) Is it simply a distinctive verbal tick? Perhaps, but I think it's more specific than that. The device often suggests grandiosity -- often a humorous grandiosity, but not always: I don't think Omar's use comes across as in any way risible. In many cases it presumes a fame on the part of the illeist (e.g. Ceasar, Doctor Doom, and in his own world Omar), but again not always -- not with The Dude, for instance, nor Gollum. But it does seem like importance -- whether genuine fame or ludicrous grandiosity -- is often tied up with it.

It occurs to me that some current technology forces a certain illeism on its users: think of facebook status updates, for instance, where the proper name is automatically attached, which, since the content is self-generated, leads to an illeistic situation even if the author doesn't intend it. (I wonder if this will lead to the device's changing rhetorical force, since it will sound more common and less forced? Or are these in a distinctive enough category that the cultural meaning won't bleed out into the other cases?)

Stephen Frug would be interested in any thoughts his Noble Readers have on the meaning conveyed by proper-name illeism -- in any context, but particularly in fictive ones. Comments are open...

_______________________
* The post also has some discussion of both third person binomialism and second person binomialism, as well as the first-person binomialism varient of illeism. Incidentally, "binomialism" seems to be a word invented in that language log post, not a standard term.

Tuesday, September 02, 2008

Palin and McCain's Base

Kevin Drum asks the following question about the religious right's (reportedly) rapturous reaction to McCain's VP pick:
The New York Times piece confirms something we already knew, namely that up until the middle of last week McCain's top choice for running mate was either Joe Lieberman or Tom Ridge. And he would have picked one of them except that word came back that the base would be furious if he chose a pro-choice veep. So he pulled a 180 and chose Palin instead. And the base has reacted rapturously. But seriously: are they really that easy to sucker? It's plain where McCain's true sentiments lie: he would have chosen a pro-choice partner if he could possibly have gotten away with it. He only picked Palin out of absolute political necessity. And yet the Christian right reacted as giddily as if he had genuinely seen the light. So I guess the answer is: yes, they really are that easy to sucker. Pretty amazing.
This gets the issue backwards, I think. Why should the religious right care about what McCain's "true sentiments" are?* They should care about what he's likely to do on issues they care about. Assuming that the latter is largely abortion, and that abortion rights are (at least currently) fought out primarily in the courts, then the fact that McCain was politically intimidated out of what he wanted into picking a candidate in line with their wishes (despite various negatives about her) is in fact be a triumph for them -- and they are wise to consider it so. Basically, McCain has just shown them that he will set aside his true sentiments to follow their wishes -- to the point of making a pick that many other people find laughable. This is precisely what they want -- given their priorities, maybe even what they should want.

It's not McCain's sentiments, but his appointments -- or, rather, the results that the latter lead to -- that will actually make a difference. If you want to restrict women's reproductive freedom, McCain's just shown he'll bow and scrape to you -- that you have, indeed, that much political pull with him.

If he'll select Palin as his VP pick, just think who he'll pick for the Supreme Court. Even if that's a nightmare for the rest of us, McCain's base is not at all unwise to celebrate it.

Suckers? Hell, no. Anyone who thinks he's a moderate, or will be pulled in that direction -- yeah, they're suckers. The religious right, on the other hand, just showed that they're the masters of McCain's universe. No wonder they're giddy.

Update: Digby, of course, gets it:
The Christian right loves Palin and are feeling their oats big time that they wielded enough clout to force a choice like this and it's quite an achievement when you think about it. (If only progressives had that kind of clout...)


________________
*Granted, this is close to a classic conservative concern -- about a candidates "heart" -- that is, I think, both deeply rooted and deeply misguided; one that they frequently focus on to their, and our, misfortune. But since it makes sense, I think, to ignore this, there is no mystery about why they are doing it; it may depart from their usual error, it seems to me that in this case the base is acting wisely.

Friday, August 29, 2008

Palin's Effect on the Race

I think that Jonathan Zasloff has it about right:
Throughout the blogosphere, the pundits are saying that the Palin nomination is either a disaster for McCain (Blue) or a game-changing work of genius (Red). I suspect it is neither, mainly because voters virtually never change their votes on a Veep.
I disagree about the way Zasloff says the biases are stacking up. I've seen conservatives say (worriedly) that Palin is a disaster (e.g.), and I've seen liberals say (worriedly) that Palin was a brilliant pick (e.g.). I think that both views are well represented on both sides of the political spectrum -- and not just in the blogosphere, either. There's been a remarkable amount of both "it's a brilliant move"/"it's a disaster" from both sides -- all very strong for their various perspectives.

But even if he ascribes the biases too simply, I think Zasloff is right about the basic issue: fundamentally it won't matter much. Maybe she'll help fire up the conservative base a bit, or win them Alaska; maybe she'll prove to be an embarrassment and depress the conservatives or fire up the liberals. But I doubt that it'll make much difference either way.

Although it sure sounds like the pick did one thing, which is knock Obama's speech right out of the single-issue lens of the mass media (and me too, I admit: I am one of those Americans they pander to, I guess). So in the short run it was a gain. (Although given how many people watched it, maybe it doesn't matter. (Incidentally, I'm not one of those 38 million, since I listened to it on the radio rather than watched it on TV.)) But I bet in the long run it won't make much difference either way.

Incidentally, Zasloff's other four points are good too -- especially his defense of Palin's common sense notion that she has no idea what the VP is supposed to do: as he points out, that has been true since the very first VP, John Adams. I think Palin should be attacked, not on this (nor on her experience, as I said below), but along the lines Obama actually did criticize her today*: given that she's on McCain's ticket, she is (presumably) committed to McCain's policies, which are mostly Bush's, which have been a disaster.) It's not who she is or what she's done, but what she -- and more importantly (what with him being the candidate and all) he -- are committed to: a disastrous style of governance that we can't afford four more years of.

* The quote is:
She seems like a compelling person ... with a terrific personal story. I'm sure that she will help make the case for Republicans, unfortunately the case is more of the same, and so ultimately John McCain is at the top of the ticket. He wants to take the country in the wrong direction, I'm assuming Gov. Palin agrees with him and his policies.
Precisely. (Obama then went on to say, wisely and correctly, that notwithstanding this it's good she broke the glass ceiling on the Republican side.)

New Orleans Yartzeit (Year Three)



Time once again to light a candle in memory of the dead, and of the great city that drowned. And to swear that, next time, we will be there for our fellow citizens, as we -- acting through our government, the collective agent of its people -- were not last time.


And to hope -- and pray, if you're the praying type -- that the dire warnings once again being spoken turn out, this time, to be needless.

And, lastly, to act so as to minimize both the chances of such storms (i.e. stop fucking with the Earth's climate) and the impact they will have upon our country when they, inevitably, do occur (i.e. have a government which manages to care for our basic infrastructure, and to treat emergency response as a sacred duty and not a patronage plan).

RIP.

A Nation Turns Its Lonely Eyes to Who?

An entire nation says, in unison, “Sarah who?”

-- John Cole

...Oh, and while I'm not commenting on current events, I liked Obama's speech a lot -- I liked that he went after conservatism and not just McCain, and so forth, the sort of things that all the liberals are saying. I'm just not interested, myself, in what I think: I want to know how it's going to effect people not insanely biased in Obama's favor. And so far I haven't seen any data on that (although I admit Pat Buchanan's fawning seems like a good sign.)

Update: I've been surfing around looking for reactions to McCain's VP pick, and here's a point I haven't seen made yet. (Which probably just means I haven't seen it, not that it hasn't been made.) And I'm far from certain about it, but in a spirit of tentative musing, I'll throw it out there.

I think that in addition to the obvious (an attempt to cash in on the "change" feeling, plus a hope to reinforce McCain's existing-if-undeserved maverick/reformist reputation*, etc, etc), this is an attempt to cash in on people's subtle -- even unconscious -- racism.

Here's what I mean. Noah Millman (via) says of Palin:
...she gives women who are angry about Hillary being passed over another reason to vote McCain; she gives fence-sitting whites who feel they "ought" to vote for Obama because of the historic nature of his candidacy an excuse to find history on the other side...
I'm simply putting a slightly darker spin on that. I think that a lot of people are uneasy despite themselves with the notion of an African American President; and putting a woman on the ticket gives them permission to feel good about themselves ("finding history") while still not voting for the black guy. (This also explains McCain's ad of last night congratulating Obama on making history: he wants to acknowledge this issue, and then claim that it's a wash; that was the first half of that two-step.)

Of course, they'll have to vote for a woman. But the VP candidate is not the Presidential candidate; and I, personally, remained convinced that racism is stronger than sexism in this country -- particularly when you force people to choose between them (rather than between a non-white male and a white male).**

I don't know if this was deliberate on McCain's part -- although given the takeover of his campaign by Rovian operatives, I'd guess that it was deliberate on someone's part.

The possible flip side to this, of course, is that a lot of I'm-not-a-racist-but-ism has latched onto Obama's lack of experience as their "objective" criteria for dismissing him, and Palin makes that argument trickier. (Doesn't mean they won't try it under the flag of IOKIYAR, of course.) But I bet they'll simply pirouette and find another cover story to give people who are hesitant an excuse for not voting for Obama.

Don't get me wrong: I'm very hopeful that, even if this is the strategy, that it won't work. And I'm certainly not saying that other factors -- her pro-life stance, the above-mentioned attempt to burnish McCain's undeserved maverick reputation, the simple lack of other good candidates -- weren't more important. But I think this is a signal about how they're going to run. After all, we all know they can't run on their ideas -- those have been shown, over the last eight years, to be entirely disastrous*** -- and Palin's lack of experience complicates their heretofore primary argument on non-issue grounds. So what's left? Sure, the lie of McCain's maverick nature; the POW card; but also the plain, basic appeal to good, old-fashioned American racism. It's a lot of what they have left.

Let's hope that we've grown beyond that. I guess we'll see in a few months.

Update 2: I do think that the Obama campaign would be stupid to try and make an issue of Palin's level of experience -- as, I fear, they are starting to do. (The same applies to liberal commentators who genuinely want to help Obama win.) I've long thought that experience shouldn't be an issue -- but either way, it's not winning ground for Democrats this year, even if it is less winning ground for Republicans than it used to be. Better to try to pocket the neutralization of the issue and move on to the issues -- the ground on which we can win and (bonus!) the ground on which elections really ought to be fought.

Update 3, from the credit-where-credit-is-due-dep't: If I'm reading this right, Sarah Palin seems to have named one of her children after Willow Rosenberg, the character from Buffy the Vampire Slayer -- who, in addition to being Buffy's best friend & sidekick, was a lesbian witch. (Just sayin'.) While it doesn't make me inclined to vote for her or anything, gotta give her mad props for that. (Oh, and for a bonus, another daughter is named after another witch from the TV show Charmed. -- I sort of wonder what her evangelical Christian base is gonna think of that...) Update to Update: Alas, this seems not to be true. Ah well.

___________________________________
* One might think that picking as a symbol of anti-corruption crusading someone who is themselves involved in a corruption scandal would be a silly move.... if one was utterly unfamiliar with the American press's willingness to regurgitate Republican talking points and ignore factual contradictions.

** No, this isn't disproved by the results of the Clinton-Obama race: I don't want to go too deeply into this, really, but I'm personally convinced that if not for racism Obama would have won more decisively and quickly. But I can see the argument on the other side.

*** My favorite line from any convention speech -- after Kucinich's undelivered zinger, anyway -- was from Bill Clinton's speech:
But on the two great questions of this election -- how to rebuild the American dream and how to restore America's leadership in the world -- [McCain] still embraces the extreme philosophy that has defined his party for more than 25 years. And it is, to be fair to all the Americans who aren't as hard- core Democrats as we, it's a philosophy the American people never actually had a chance to see in action fully until 2001, when the Republicans finally gained control of both the White House and the Congress. Then we saw what would happen to America if the policies they had talked about for decades actually were implemented. And look what happened.
To me, this is the basic point to make, over and over. Bush implemented conservatism, and it was a disaster; let's go a different way. (And one of the reasons that I liked Obama's speech is that he did go some distance in that direction.)

Thursday, August 28, 2008

Quote of the Day

"They say it's gavel to gavel coverage, but maybe they're just talking about the gavels."

-- My wife, about the available live video coverage of the DNC

Ezra Nails It

Ezra Kline has come up with the perfect description of the strange dynamic between McCain campaign and the press:
It's amazing how dumb [the McCain campaign] seem to think the press corps is. And its amazing how dumb the press corps is willing to be. It's like watching Tom Sawyer run for president: "You know what's great? Being a bad speaker! And having very few people show up at my events! Nothing better than the peace and quiet of an sparsely attended townhall. I'd hate to be cool and flashy and eloquent. What could be more suspicious then that? Meanwhile, you should see what I'm going to do later. It's going to be great!"
As the big boys say: Heh. Indeed.

While I'm linking to Ezra Klein, I might mention that thus far his blog has been my favorite source for coverage of a convention that I am -- frankly -- mostly ignoring.* This post did a good job of summing up my (and other's) fears about how the convention is going. And, although not a characteristic post about the convention, this is my favorite post to come out of the convention so far. So check out his blog's convention coverage if you're interested in that sort of thing.

______________________________
*These things are now meaningless except as week-long advertisements; and I wonder how many people watch them, except for political junkies who have already made up their minds anyway. I'll probably watch Obama's speech tonight -- the main event -- but for the most part it seems like a good week to get some work done.

Saturday, August 23, 2008

Biden

Or so everyone's reporting as of now (early Saturday morning).

My first reaction: Meh. Coulda been worse. Doesn't raise my enthusiasm. Depressingly centrist & "safe". I hate that Obama picked someone who voted for the war. But better than Kaine or Bayh, I think. Good that he's aggressive in debate; Obama could probably use an attack dog in the rest of the campaign. Overall: Meh. But it coulda been worse.

Atrios is a bit more upbeat than I.

OK, on to November....

Update (Monday, 8/25): My favorite comment on the selection so far comes in two parts, both from the comments section of Making Light. First, Nina Katrina:
Biden makes a decent Tommy Lee Jones to Obama's Will Smith.
And then Magenta Griffith:
Obama is Will Smith, Biden is Tommy Lee Jones - and McCain is the giant cockroach they have to defeat!
Word.

Sunday, August 17, 2008

Sir Penguin

Via Hilzoy, this BBC video of a penguin, Nils Olav, being knighted -- yes, knighted, really -- at the Edinburgh Zoo is about as delightful as anything you'll find on the web. Watch it for the sheer joy of it -- to say nothing of Sir Olav's incredible dignity and poise as those strange primates did whatever they were doing.


Sir Nils Olav inspects the Royal Norwegian Guard.

Photo from here -- along with a great many other photographs, including some of the bronze statue of Sir Olav.

Sir Nils Olav's Wikipedia page is here.

Thursday, August 14, 2008

From a Hitherto Unreported Conversation in the Studio of Peter Gabriel, 1984

"I need some help with this. It's a great tune, but I'm struggling with the lyric. I can't figure out which tool works best."

"Tool? Lyrics? You lost me."

"Let me play you a few."

I want to be.... your lawn mower

"Lawn mower? What?"

"Y'know... I want to keep you in shape, help you look good, be the thing that caresses you..."

"Cuts you down if you grow too high?"

"Okay, maybe not. How about this:"

I want to be.... your screwdriver

"Screwdriver?"

"The most useful tool there is. Plus, y'know, the pun."

"Spare me. Next?"

I want to be.... your bread toaster

"Toaster? You've got to be kidding me."

"Sure. The toaster is the friendliest kitchen appliance. 'Lives there a man with a soul so dead/He's never to his toaster said--'"

"Enough. No. Toaster will not do. And adding "bread" to make the rhythm work is just lame. You got anything else?"

"Yeah, but nothing I like. Y'know... Egg beater, air conditioner, tape recorder, sledgehammer... nothing seems to work."

"Wait, what about that last one?"

"What, egg beater?"

"No, the other. Sledgehammer."

"Sledgehammer? You've got to be kidding me. I want to smash her to bits?"

"No you want to build her things. Y'know... train tracks, airplanes..."

"That's ridiculous. Way too violent. Anyway a screwdriver is much more useful in building generally."

"Yeah, but you have the whole juvenile-sex pun thing working against you."

"What, like you've never heard the expression 'hammer her?' No way. I am not going with sledgehammer."

"Fine, whatever. You asked my advice, I gave it."

"Hmm. We'll work on it later. In the meantime, what about this other lyric I'm working on: Bunker hill? Highgate hill? Sparrow hill? Signal hill? What do you think sounds best?"

Monday, August 11, 2008

(e) Those that are variations on Borges; (f) Those that are simply links to other posts

If you look closely at a few of my blogpost labels, you'll see that I have been a fan of the famous passage from Borges's essay* "The Analytical Language of John Wilkins":
These ambiguities, redundancies and deficiencies remind us of those which doctor Franz Kuhn attributes to a certain Chinese encyclopaedia entitled 'Celestial Empire of benevolent Knowledge'. In its remote pages it is written that the animals are divided into: (a) belonging to the emperor, (b) embalmed, (c) tame, (d) sucking pigs, (e) sirens, (f) fabulous, (g) stray dogs, (h) included in the present classification, (i) frenzied, (j) innumerable, (k) drawn with a very fine camelhair brush, (l) et cetera, (m) having just broken the water pitcher, (n) that from a long way off look like flies. (Trans. Lilia Graciela Vázquez)
This passage from a fairly obscure Borges piece was made famous by its citation by Michel Foucault in The Order of Things, although its fame has now out-stripped those who heard of it that way. In some ways, it is the quintessential Borges passage -- the one sentence that best conveys his spirit. (That, of course, is a challenge: anyone got a better one?)

Anyway, in one of the games that make Making Light such a delightful blog to read, Jim McDonald, aping Borges, has now proposed the following classification of novels:
a) Those that are best-sellers, (b) those that were assigned to you in school, (c) those that you feel you have already read even though you have not, (d) classics, (e) those that are not read as the author intended, (f) those that many intend to read “some day,” (g) fantasy trilogies, (h) those that are otherwise not flawed, (i) those that were written on manual typewriters, (j) those that can be judged by their covers, (k) those that were padded by their designers during production to appear longer than they are, (l) those that are only called ‘novel’ by courtesy, (m) those that have been condensed by Readers Digest, (n) those that look well upon the shelf.
The comments that follow are filled with additions, as well as some revisions and other ions. Check them out if you found the above at all amusing.

(See also the list of types of novels from the first chapter of Italo Calvino's incomparable novel If on a Winter's Night a Traveler.)

Then, via comments in an earlier Making Light post, we have the following classification of people who site the Borges quote cited above:
Citers of John Wilkins are divided into: (a) government employees, (b) tenured faculty, (c) LIS graduates, (d) freshmen, (e) the transgendered, (f) Mac users, (g) laid-off dotcommers, (h) programmers who write recursive code, (i) those on their fourth espresso of the day, (j) webloggers, (k) those using XML with a valid DTD, (l) et cetera, and so on, und so weiter, (m) Microsoft users, (n) geeks.
Currently I fall into (f), (j), (n) and arguably (l).

Any other Borges-on-Wilkins pastiches that my Noble Readers have noticed?

Update: While I'm on the subject of Borges's fabulous non-fiction (in both senses), let me link to this post of mine from a few months ago, which reprints, in its entirety, one of those fabulous non-fictions. If you haven't read the piece, do: it's simply amazingly wonderful.

_____________________________
* Yes, essay: at the very least, it's included in the Selected Non-Fictions volume, not the Collected Fictions volume. But in Borges, these categories always look like flies (from a long way off, anyway).

Friday, August 08, 2008

Recent Amusements

I seem to have entered another of my periodic blogging lulls -- as usual, this doesn't mean much of anything: I'm working on other stuff and haven't had anything particular to say, is all. I'll be back soon enough (FSM willing).

In the meantime, here are a few diversions you might find entertaining.

• Bach's Toccata and Fugue in D minor visualized -- this is truly stunning stuff, well worth watching. (via). If you like it, the same guy has done a bunch of other videos too -- try his visualization of Bach's Little Fugue. Now if he'd just get to work on the Well-Tempered Clavier and Goldberg Variations, I'd be a happy man....

• Speaking of Bach, if anyone hasn't seen 32 Short Films About Glenn Gould, it's a great film. Just sayin'.

• Two comics about Gricean conversational maxims. How can you not love that? (via Zompist.)

• Who knew that there was a list of the Forbes Fictional 15 -- the wealthiest fictional characters? Highly amusing, although I am curious where they go the various numbers (if, indeed, they were not just randomly generated, as seems reasonably likely....)

• Someone made a short film out of Terry Bisson's classic short story, "They're Made of Meat" (which I've linked to several times before.) The story's much better (and, in my head, very different in tone and overall atmosphere), so if you haven't read the story, do yourself a favor and read it. But if you have read the story, the film's kind of fun. (Bisson himself seems to have made it into a play -- which, given that the original is entirely in dialogue, seems to mean primarily that he changed the formatting. Unlike the film, the play is virtually indistinguishable from the story...)

• Three Quarks Daily reposts a terrific Yehuda Amichai poem (in translation).

• Andrew Sullivan unearths a gem from Craigslist.

• If you've seen McCain's various attack ads against Obama, you might find this parody amusing.

And that's all for now, folks.

Thursday, July 31, 2008

588 Days After...

...his last post at the whiskey bar, the great Billmon, who for a long time was my very favorite blogger, (his old site is down but archives of it can be found here, here and here) has put up a post at the Daily Kos. (via)

And there was much rejoicing...

Movies That I Wish Were Not Coming Out

There are lots of movies -- classic, current, in production, hypothetical, and impossible -- that I have no desire to see. (And lots of interesting-looking ones that I look forward to seeing, natch.) But it takes a special something extra not only to not want to see a film, but to actively wish that the film in question didn't exist -- or, since all three seem to be movies in production (at the very least, not yet released), wish that they would somehow derail before their public debut.

Three such have recently crossed my attention: one I knew about, and have been long dreading; the other two are news to me.

1.
The one I am least sure about -- one which I can imagine I might even end up liking -- is Oliver Stone's forthcoming biopic about George W. Bush, "W". Stone is, of course, a leftie, and the description hardly looks like an exoneration. Yet somehow I wish he wasn't doing it. Partly because it seems that the film will, inevitably, make Bush overly sympathetic just by focusing on him (just as it will, even more inevitably, not give full due to the stories of his victims). Even more, it's because I think it will portray Bush's vast clusterfuck of a presidency in a way that trivializes the roots of the scope of its disaster: it seems inevitable that the film will adopt the tempting (but ultimately both false and exculpatory of the true agents) analysis that Bush was simply incompetent, ambitious above his station, or misled by sinister advisers (i.e. Cheney) When, in fact, the roots of the Bush disaster are comparatively little in his (admittedly vast) incompetence and lie far more in the fact that he was a conservative president with a conservative (for 3/4 of his term) and compliant (for all) congress, and thus he implemented conservative policies with a free hand and unquestioning heart. To make Bush a Shakespearean figure, even if a fool, both overstates his personal importance and prepares the grounds for future disaster. (And I fear Stone, given his tendency to see Shakespearean tragic figures in recent Presidents,* will in fact try to play him as a tragic figure -- a Macbeth overcome with "vaulting ambition", an Othello naive in his trust of foul advisers, and a [were any Shakespearean protagonists simply incompetent?].) But above all, I am simply sick of this foul man and hope to think of him after January 20 only in the context of the news about his war-crimes trials and the ongoing revelations about the true depths of his administration's depravity due to congressional hearings and the like.** And I resent Stone for drawing my attention back to Bush, above all in what I suspect will be an (albeit probably only marginally) exculpatory context.

2.
The one that is the most clearly idiotic (to the degree that even Hollywood executives*** should have been able to see it) is the forthcoming sequel to the brilliant film Donnie Darko, "S Darko", about the grown-up adventures of Donnie's little sister Samantha, featuring meteorites and a rabbit.... no, sadly, I am not kidding, although I admit that when I first saw this on Wikipedia I thought (and hoped) that someone was playing a joke on that easily-marked internet institution. But no. Someone really thought that this was a good idea. (And not Richard Kelly, the director of the original film, who might at least have won a hearing if he wished to make such a film.) I presume I don't have to spell out the true stupidity of this idea to anyone who has seen the original film; for the rest of you... go see it, before its existence is polluted by a terrible sequel. It's a great movie, one that bears repeated re-watching, at once a great SF film and a great portrait of daily life in a 1988 suburban family. But the idea of a sequel, at all, is silly; and this idea... well, it's worthy of having been come up with by the Bush administration, put it that way. Anyway, while this has started filming (according to Wikipedia), it seems farthest from the screen of any of the three, so let's hope that something goes wrong and it crashes and burns before ever being finished.

3.
Finally, the one I have been long dreading: the forthcoming film of Watchmen, a graphic novel which I continue to maintain (in the face of a surprising number of detractors given its safely canonical status) is one of the great works of art of the second half of the Twentieth Century, and certainly of the new and exciting medium it helped usher into existence. But Alan Moore has a very bad track record of having filmed versions of his work, which range from the unspeakable to the middling, but which have never yet come close to the genius of his original works: partly because his instincts are so anti-Hollywood, partly because his work is so tied into its medium (both that of comics and his original language) as to be unfilmable. As I wrote a year ago tomorrow, "It can't possibly be any good, and will simply tarnish a great book with whatever dirt rubs off due to its memetic proximity." Unfortunately, in our culture, film versions of books tend to swamp the imagination, inevitably coloring the original works, usually to the detriment of the latter. And this is a book that I hate to see tarnished.

Based on the trailer (warning: visual-imagination pollution at the link), it looks like a lot of the film will be visually close to the graphic novel... although the exceptions are truly horrific (Silk Spectre's costume? And who is that twelve-year-old boy they got to play Ozymandias?) But even if they maintain the basic story and themes of the book - and is thus simply mediocre rather than actively abominable (and the latter still seems like a distinct possibility) I find it practically impossible that the film will be as brilliant as a movie as Watchmen was as a comic. Watchmen was a brilliant use of the medium, expanding it in dozens of ways (and directions). Thus even a good film will necessarily betray the original work. But can the film, from a major studio, really be faithful to the subtle critique of power of the original work (let alone to its characterizations, the beauty of its language, the humor of its pastiches...)? Nah. At best it'll be a film with the subtly of a decent superhero movie like Dark Knight (which I liked, but didn't love): that is, good in comparison to the majority of the recent outings of the genre but hardly on a par with what Watchmen was and is. And at worse? I shudder to think.

Of all the films on this list, Watchmen is the one I suspect I'll end up seeing. But I wish I didn't have the option: I wish I'd never seen the trailer: because I wish that they had continued to fail to make it (as they did, actively, for years). For what it's worth, Alan Moore agrees with me on this -- wishes the film hadn't been made -- and apparently talked Terry Gilliam (the one director one can almost imagine doing justice to it) out of doing it on the (valid) grounds the book was unfilmable.

In ancient Athens, the citizens practiced Ostracism, voting certain citizens "off the island" (to mix the historical and the recent), which meant their 10-year banishment from the city. As a free speech absolutist, I would never recommend, nor support, any equivalent for works of art. But I wish that the only restraints that freedom can tolerate -- self-restraint, reasoned criticism, and wisdom -- had worked in all three of these cases. And -- despite the odds against it, at least in some of these cases -- I wish all of them quick disappearances from the box office, and a quick passing from public memory.

_______________________________
* I remember Stone saying in interviews that he saw Nixon as a Shakespearean figure, undone by his own character; and he clearly saw JFK's assassination as a tragedy for the country. Interestingly, in doing those two Sixties presidents, he has failed to portray the one president in modern times whose life actually holds good material for a Shakespearean-style tragedy, Lyndon Johnson (probably because seeing the tragedy is precluded by his "JFK's death destroyed everything" worldview).

** Hey, we've all got our fantasies...

*** Assuming, that is, that they are as stupid and venal as they are so often portrayed as being in the movies... a fact for which the existence of S. Darko gives a certain amount of evidence.

Saturday, July 26, 2008

Poem of the Day: Pied Beauty

Pied Beauty

GLORY be to God for dappled things—
For skies of couple-colour as a brinded cow;
For rose-moles all in stipple upon trout that swim;
Fresh-firecoal chestnut-falls; finches’ wings;
Landscape plotted and pieced—fold, fallow, and plough;
And áll trádes, their gear and tackle and trim.

All things counter, original, spare, strange;
Whatever is fickle, freckled (who knows how?)
With swift, slow; sweet, sour; adazzle, dim;
He fathers-forth whose beauty is past change:
Praise him.

-- Gerard Manley Hopkins (1844–89)

A beautiful poem indeed -- and one on my mind today. So I thought I'd share it with you.

Thursday, July 24, 2008

Diversions, Curiosities and Miscellaneous Points of Interest

I found everything linked to here interesting, fun, beautiful or otherwise worthy of attention. It's all non-politics, because that's the mood I'm in right now. And some of these links are old (in internet years), although I think none are the worse for that. Enjoy.

• Twelve youtubes of Tom Lehrer in concert, playing some of his classics. If you love Tom Lehrer -- or if you have no idea who he is -- check these out. Really.

• Alison Bechdel's "Compulsory Reading": if you've missed this fabulous strip by the brilliant cartoonist Alison Bechdel, go read it. It's compulsory.*



• Five proofs of the existence of Santa Claus in the mode of Thomas Aquinas. It's terrific. My favorite is probably the utterly-inarguable number four:
The existence of Santa Claus Can be proved in five ways... The fourth way is taken from the grades which are found in Christmas spirit. Indeed, in this world, among men there are some of more and some of less Christmas spirit. But "more" and "less" is said of diverse things according as they resemble in their diverse ways something which is the "maximum." Therefore there must be something which has the most Christmas spirit, and this we call Santa Claus.
Read the rest.

• Unlike many superheroes, Batman has no superpowers; therefore, in theory, his exploits could happen. Right? Scientific American investigates the realism of Batman, and concludes "Batman could exist -- but not for long."

• Kitty Genovese's brutal murder with 38 witnesses looking on and doing nothing -- which became a modern parable of apathy and indifference -- is mentioned in a lot of history books, although (as for many, I suspect) it's most vivid from its role in art such as Harlan Ellison's "The Whimper of Whipped Dogs" and Moore & Gibbons's Watchmen. Well, a contemporary investigation shows that the mythic aspect -- the 38 indifferent bystanders -- may be largely a myth, originating in the early NY Times article that brought it to the public's attention. The author argues that the police were most likely called, possibly many times (it was back before such calls were tape recorded) and that few of the witnesses understood -- or, even, had reason to understand -- what was in progress. Worth a read if you've heard of this famous case.

• The Big Lebowski has not been served well by for-TV editing. If you know the movie (and if you don't, it's just brilliant, go see it), this youtube is absolutely hilarious. (Maybe even if you don't know it... but I find it hard to judge that.)

• Classic photos re-done in Logo. (In particular for fans of Vik Muniz's memory series.)

• Photos from space -- stunningly beautiful. (via)

• The New York Times reprints some classic Mad magazine "fold-ins". Jeeze these are fun. (In reference to this profile of their creator, Al Jaffe, interesting in its own right.)

• If you find it interesting (as I do) that "18 is the only number (other than 0) that is twice the sum of its digits", then check out this page on What's special about this number? If not -- don't.

• Comics geekery links (probably of specialized interest):
- 6 Creepiest Comic Book Characters of All Time (particularly funny)
- Wolverine from the 50's (You really need the background for this one)

• A detailed comparison of Cricket and Baseball on Wikipedia.

• Always-thoughtful blogger (and college professor) Tim Burke thinks about why negative feelings/stereotypes about academia have purchase in our culture. His commentators also weigh in interestingly. (For more interesting Burke blogging, check out his thoughts inspired by the recent book The Ten Cent Plague.)

_________________________
* I make no apologies.